PDA

View Full Version : Which is better?


Melonie Tomb Raider
03-09-07, 07:49
Ok, same drawing, different style as far as linework and color. I'd really, really, really appreciate some input. Which is your favorite?

First:

http://img516.imageshack.us/img516/4595/johnxter11vl8.jpg

Second:

http://img488.imageshack.us/img488/2866/johnxterremasteredcopylu5.jpg

george_croft
03-09-07, 07:55
I like both, but i prefer the coloring of the second one! :)

Autolycus
03-09-07, 07:57
I much prefer the second one as i think the colours stand out more.

ashnar
03-09-07, 08:07
second one. the colors around the head are a much clearer focus point, giving the whole drawing balance. Nice pics by the way:tmb:

jackali
03-09-07, 08:37
I much prefer the colouring of the head in the second one, they stand out much more. Although, the line over its left eye is not as clear as maybe it should be, in fact it is rather hard to see that it is there.

However, I prefer the colouring of the clothing on the first one, it is more subtle and shows more detail.

Perhaps you could try putting the second head onto the first body?

Other than that they are both brilliant. Great work! :tmb:

nicola1986
03-09-07, 09:19
They are both great but I love the colour in the second one :tmb:

Kerrigan
03-09-07, 09:46
I like the first one better.The colours seem well balanced, more natural and easier to look at.Overall, I prefer the first picture's mood.

Legends
03-09-07, 10:13
I like the second one.

RAID
03-09-07, 10:15
Second one

Anajrob
03-09-07, 10:16
I much prefer the colouring of the head in the second one, they stand out much more. Although, the line over its left eye is not as clear as maybe it should be, in fact it is rather hard to see that it is there.

However, I prefer the colouring of the clothing on the first one, it is more subtle and shows more detail.

Perhaps you could try putting the second head onto the first body?

Other than that they are both brilliant. Great work! :tmb:

My thoughts exactly! :tmb:

MUN33B
03-09-07, 10:17
2nd one - though they are both brilliant :)

Alex Fly
03-09-07, 10:23
They are both great but I have a small preference for the first one. :)

MiCkiZ88
03-09-07, 12:32
The second one. Green eyes = yummy :)
Very nice work on both though! :tmb:

Nemo_91
03-09-07, 12:39
First one. :tmb:

Legend of Lara
03-09-07, 13:56
The first one is better in terms of detail but the second has lovely vivid colours. Love them both. :D

Dakaruch
03-09-07, 13:58
They are both great but I have a small preference for the first one. :)

i second that! it's really hard to choose one :p

Sedge
03-09-07, 13:59
I like the first one better.The colours seem well balanced, more natural and easier to look at.Overall, I prefer the first picture's mood.
Yup, that's what I think also. :) The second one just has too much contrast for my eye.. O_o First one is much, much nicer to look at. And if you made a comic with him I'd rather watch the style above than below. But it really seems to depend on everyone's own taste.. :p

Nannonxyay
03-09-07, 15:20
I like the first one lol. I'm a larry lol. The only reason is because the second one looks too colourful and the first ones colours look less i dunno weird lol.

danitiwa
03-09-07, 15:23
Second one.:p

James_Rutland
03-09-07, 16:39
I prefer the Second one, but they are both spot on! :tmb:

Melonie Tomb Raider
03-09-07, 17:11
Thanks everyone. I'm trying different techniques, so I appreciate your input so much. :jmp:

Sara Croft
03-09-07, 17:22
Definatly the second one, because the colors stand more out, and he is easier to notice.. The first one is very nicely done too, but a bit too light colored. :)

larson n natla
03-09-07, 18:51
first one looks natural the second looks a bit like its been on the sun beds


both are great though better than i could ever do :o

lararoxs
03-09-07, 19:53
I like the second but i love them both!