PDA

View Full Version : GameSpot gives TRA X360 a *7.5*

Ring_of_Fire
27-10-07, 22:44
The Bad
Doesn't take many chances with the Tomb Raider formula + Minor frame rate issues.
Read the review (http://www.gamespot.com/xbox360/adventure/tombraider10thanniversaryedition/review.html?om_act=convert&om_clk=gssummary&tag=summary;review) to find out the good! The PS2/PC versions got an 8.0 because of the smooth framerate. PSP is rated the same as the X360.


Also, I am seeing major glitches for the Xbox 360 being posted on this forum. GameSpot could have give it a 6.5 saying "Too many glitches". :D
Thorpe
28-10-07, 01:00
There's a few glitches present in this that I never experienced on the PS2 version. I'm assuming these things popped up during porting. Shame they didn't test this one out a bit further because some glitches were fairly obvious.

As for the review, it feels like an edited version of the other consoles' reviews. Still - 7.5 is a good. If I'm rating on their rating scale (.5), it would be an 8.0.
Angelus
28-10-07, 01:32
The reviews don't seem to go any lower than 6, so it looks like the 360 port has got a fairly average response. I wonder what the score would be if the graphics were next-gen...
James_Rutland
28-10-07, 01:38
Wow. I like this review. He knows what TR Is about. And was right about It being the best TR In years. :D
Sir Croft
28-10-07, 01:57
The reviews don't seem to go any lower than 6, so it looks like the 360 port has got a fairly average response. I wonder what the score would be if the grpahics were next-gen...

I'm pretty sure the grade would be 8.0, or even don't change. Well, I think it's a fair grade. :)
MMAN
28-10-07, 02:08
Isn't this just a slightly edited copy of the original PS2/PC reviews (with a .5 reduction)? There are various phrases in it that give a big deja vu feeling. That's not such as bad thing though as this is one of the better reviews I've seen of it.
gtkilla
28-10-07, 06:04
Isn't this just a slightly edited copy of the original PS2/PC reviews (with a .5 reduction)? There are various phrases in it that give a big deja vu feeling. That's not such as bad thing though as this is one of the better reviews I've seen of it.

It's the same review, but with an additional paragraph or two explaining the 360 stuff.
Grenade
28-10-07, 11:33
The reviews don't seem to go any lower than 6, so it looks like the 360 port has got a fairly average response. I wonder what the score would be if the grpahics were next-gen...
Yep, I agree. :)
Alex Fly
28-10-07, 11:49
Thanks for posting ! :tmb: