PDA

View Full Version : rate all the tomb raider games....


robm_2007
19-04-08, 10:45
give a 1 to the best TR game, then a 2 to the second best, etc., and then finally, an 8 to the worst one.
mine is:

TR- 5
2- 1
3- 3
LR- 4
Chronicles- 6
AOD- 2
Legend- 8
Anniversary- 7
i liked all of them except L and A.

Seb_01225
19-04-08, 10:51
AOD - 1
TR:2 - 2
TR - 3
TRLR - 4
Anniversary - 5
Chronicles - 6
TR3 - 7
Legend - 8


GO AOD GO. oh god how i love that game!

pEhouse
19-04-08, 10:52
here we go again... :p

TR III - 1
TRLR - 2
TR II - 3
TR - 4
Anniversary - 5
Chronicles - 6
Legend - 7
AOD - 8

But I don't discriminate, I like all games in some ways.

zappo3000
19-04-08, 10:59
i couldn't ever choose...

scion05
19-04-08, 11:10
They really should pin this :rolleyes:


:p

Domino
19-04-08, 11:17
Tomb Raider II - 8
Tomb Raider - 7
Tomb Raider III - 6
The Last revelation - 5
Chronicles - 4
Angel of Darkness - 3
Legend - 2
Anniversary - 1

Endow
19-04-08, 11:32
Tomb Raider - 1
Anniversary - 2
Tomb Raider II - 3
The Last Revelation - 4
Legend - 5
Chronicles - 6
Adventures of Lara Croft - 7


Haven't played AoD.

Vertigo
19-04-08, 11:40
The Last Revelation - 1
Tomb Raider - 2
Tomb Raider 2 - 3
AoD - 4
Tomb Raider 3 - 5
Anniversary - 6
Chronicles - 7
Legend - 8 mwahaha!

AODdigger
19-04-08, 11:45
*cough*... :)




Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness - 1

Tomb Raider IV: The Last Revelation - 2

Tomb Raider V: Chronicles - 3

Tomb Raider III: The Adventures of Lara Croft - 4

Tomb Raider Anniversary - 5

Tomb Raider II: The Dagger of Xian - 6

Tomb Raider Legend.... 8 :p

Haven't played TR I.

Larapink
19-04-08, 12:31
Anniversary- 1
Legend- 2
2- 3
TR- 4
Chronicles- 5
3- 6
LR- 7
AOD- Not even going to bother to rate this, it was bad very bad. :mad:

Angel_14
19-04-08, 12:40
TR2 - 1
TR1 - 2
AoD - 3
TR3 - 4
TR5 - 5
TR4 - 6
TRA - 7
Legend - 8

But I like all of them =)

Aurimas
19-04-08, 12:47
.

tranniversary119
19-04-08, 12:52
1. Tomb Raider II
2. Tomb Raider III
3. Tomb Raider I
4. Tomb Raider: Legend
5. Tomb Raider: Anniversary
6. Tomb Raider IV

Chronicles was really bad tbh, to short, depressing, not tomb raiderish.
Angel Of Darkness- Great Storyline, Music was great, Controls sucked though so that basically ruined the game play for me.

Lux veritata
19-04-08, 12:52
Tr4-1
Tr1-2
Traod-3
Tr2-4
Tr3-5
Tr5-6
Tra-7
Trl-8

MiCkiZ88
19-04-08, 12:53
Weird rating system.. anyways, from best to worst:


Tomb Raider IV: The Last Revelation - 1
Tomb Raider II - 2
Tomb Raider - 3
Tomb Raider III - 4
Tomb Raider AoD - 5
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 6
Tomb Raider Chronicles - 7
Lara Croft: Legend - 8


I love the first 5 on my list, and like the 3 others, but Tomb Raider IV has the best level design, locations, voice actors, cutscenes, enemies, music.. all of it is just perfect IMO. Legend.. ehh.. it has nice arcade style 3rd person shooter touch to it, but the levels were too short, linear, non complex, easy, and it was filled with cutscenes and chatter. Not a tomb raider IMO.

Last Angel
19-04-08, 13:02
Tomb Raider AOD - 1
Tomb Raider 2 - 2
Tomb Raider - 3
Tomb Raider : The Last Revelation - 4
Tomb Raider 3 - 5
Tomb Raider Aniversary - 6
Tomb Raider Chronicles - 7
Tomb Raider: Legend - 8

Chocolate
19-04-08, 13:03
I've not played all TR games; but judging from videos, watching others play those games and everything else like storylines and such, I will try and cast my votes as fair as possible.

1. TR4
2. TR3
3. TR2
4. TR7
5. TR6
6. TR1
7. TR5
8. TRA

raiderfun
19-04-08, 13:05
TRII - 1
TRA - 2
TrIII - 3
TRI - 4
TRL - 5
TR6 - 6
TR5 - 7
TR4 - 8

:)

Zique
19-04-08, 13:06
Tomb Raider - 1
Tomb Raider 2 - 2
Tomb Raider 3 - 3
Chronicles - 4
Angel of Darkness - 5
Anniversary - 6
The Last Revelation - 7
Legend - 8

(aod would be better than chronicles, with it wasn't the controls)

Carbonek_0051
19-04-08, 13:08
1.TR1
2.TRL
3.TRA
4.TR3
5.TRC
6.TR2
7.TRLR
8.TRAoD

da tomb raider!
19-04-08, 13:13
1: Tomb Raider III
2: Tomb Raider
3: Tomb Raider Chronicles
4: Tomb Raider II
5: Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation
6: Lara Croft Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness
7: "Lara Croft Tomb Raider": Legend
8: "Lara Croft Tomb Raider": Anniversary

:wve:

Sweets
19-04-08, 15:19
1. Tomb Raider 2
2. Tomb Raider/Anniversary
3. Tomb Raider The Last Revelation
4. Tomb Raider 3
5. AOD
6.Legend
7.Chronicles

Mad Tony
19-04-08, 15:25
Tomb Raider III - 1
Tomb Raider II - 2
Tomb Raider - 3
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation - 4
Tomb Raider: Chronicles - 5
Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness - 6

AmericanAssassin
19-04-08, 15:29
1. Tomb Raider 10
2. Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation 9.75
3. Tomb Raider II: Starring Lara Croft 9.5
4. Tomb Raider: Anniversary 9
5. Tomb Raider: Legend 9
6. Tomb Raider: Chronicles 8.5
7. Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness 7.5
8. Tomb Raider III: Adventures of Lara Croft 7

Hairhelmet12
19-04-08, 16:57
I cant choose thay were all great!:D

domina
19-04-08, 16:59
TR- 4
2- 1
3- 6
LR- 5
Chronicles- 7
AOD- 8
Legend- 3
Anniversary- 2

Encore
19-04-08, 17:12
1. TR III
2. TR II
3. TR I
4. TR Last Revelation
5. TR Anniversary
6. Chronicles
7. AoD
8. Legend

Obscure
19-04-08, 21:45
1. Legend
2. The Last Revelation
3. Adventures of Lara Croft
4. Angel of Darkness
5. Dagger of Xian
6. Anniversary
7. Atlantean Scion
8. Chronicles

Drone
19-04-08, 21:49
I rate these 6 games

AOD
TR1
TR4
TR3
TR2
TRC

Rivendell
19-04-08, 21:54
Tomb Raider III - 1
Tomb Raider II - 2
Tomb Raider - 3
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation - 4
Tomb Raider: Chronicles - 5
Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness - 6

*Grins* I like what you did there. ;)

The order for me:

TR1 - 1
TR4 - 2
TR3 - 3
TR2 - 4
TR6 - 5
TRA - 6
TR5 - 7
legend - 8

:wve:
Though if it wasn't from 1-8 points, it'd look:

TR1/TR4 - tied first
TR2/TR3 - tied second
TR6/TR:A - tied third
TR5 - a bit lower down
legend - fell through the rotten floorboards and now lies in the basement somewhere.

Eddie Haskell
19-04-08, 22:00
#1---The Original (as far above TR3 as TR3 is above Legend)
#2---TR3
#3---TR2
#4---TLR
#5---AoD
#6---Chronicles
#7---Anniversary
#8---Legend

As a side note, my random playlist on my pc contains 4500 songs or so and as I started to do this list the theme from TR3 came on. Coincidence, or is fate wanting me to play again? :D

EDIT:
I noticed that quite a few are not listing the original game. Have that many not played it?

Sweets
19-04-08, 22:12
Its funny how most classic raiders rated Crystal Dynamics Tomb Raider games low on their lists, but if you were to do this on a casual gamers forum or at gaming sites like IGN and Gamespot the results would be quite different. Crystal Dynamics seem to have lost the faith of alot of the Tomb Raider fans that have stuck with the series for so long, and its a shame :(

I haven't lost complete faith yet as I thought Anniversary was a step in the right direction, but they need to take a big leap for Underworld to really impress me.

Tihocan9
19-04-08, 22:15
1. Tr2
2.tr1
3.tr3
4.trl
5.trlr
6.tra
7.trc
8.traod

NightWish
19-04-08, 22:17
TR1
TR4
TRaod
TR2
tr3
TrA
Tr5
TrL

TR 4 LIFE
20-04-08, 00:55
#1:TR legend
#2:TR 2
#3:TR3
#4:TR
#5:TR anniversary
#6:TR last revelation
#7:TR AOD

didn't rate TRV because I never played it!!;)

oocladableeblah
20-04-08, 00:59
TR1-6: 1
TR7-A: 3
:p
TR: 2
TR2: 1
TR3: 3
TR4: 4
TR5: 6
TR6: 5
TR7: 7
TRA: 8

Braider
20-04-08, 15:00
If the control system in AOD as better I would rate it no1, but is they were terrible it drops to no8!!


Legend 1
TR3 2
TR2 3
LR 4
Anniversary 5
Tr 6
Cronicles 7
AOD 8

Mona Sax
20-04-08, 15:09
1. TR1, 3 and 4 - 9/10
4. TR2 and TRA - 8/10
6. TRL and AOD - 6/10
8. TRC - 4/10

Margot*Croft
20-04-08, 15:34
AoD - 1
Legend - 2
TRChronicles - 3
TR2 - 4
TR1 - 5
TRAnniversary - 6
TR3 - 7
TR4 - 8

Nemo_91
20-04-08, 15:42
TR1 - 1
TR3 - 2
TR4 - 3
TRAOD - 4
TR2 - 5
Anniversary - 6
Legend - 7
Chronicles - 8

Tidus
20-04-08, 17:43
I'll probably be butchered for mine:

1. Tomb Raider 3
2. Tomb Raider 1
3. Tomb Raider Chronicles
4. Tomb Raider 2
5. Legend
6. Angel of Darkness
7. Anniversary
8. Last Revelation

SparkleCroft07
20-04-08, 17:45
TRIII
TRC
TRII
TLR
TRAOD
TRLR
TRA

(Never played TRI, so can't comment on that.)

kooky
20-04-08, 17:48
1. Tomb raider the last revelation
2. Tomb Raider 3
3. Angel Of Darkness/Tomb Raider 6
4. Tomb Raider
5. Tomb Raider 2
6. Chronicles
7. Legend
8. Anniversary

:D

Ward Dragon
20-04-08, 18:16
1) TR1 -- 9/10
2) TR3 -- 9/10

3) TR5 -- 8/10
4) AOD -- 8/10
5) TRA -- 8/10
6) TR2 -- 8/10

7) TR4 -- 7/10 (great game, but excessive back-tracking in certain parts really got to me)

8) Legend -- 4/10 with headset, 6/10 with voice volume off

NemesisxAngelus
20-04-08, 19:00
1 TR:AoD
2 TR:2
3 TR:1
4 TR:LR
5 TR:C
6 TR:3

KIKO
20-04-08, 19:03
So I changed my mind again about the bests list.
Here it goes:

TR1- 1
TR3- 2
TR2- 3
TRA- 4
TRL- 5
TR4- 6
TRAOD- 7
TR5- 8

Deamonella
20-04-08, 19:22
Tr3 - 1
Trl - 2
Traod - 3
Tr2 - 4
Tra - 5
Tr1 - 6
Tr5 - 7
Tr4 - 8

takamotosan
25-05-08, 16:23
TR-2
TRII-3
TRIII-6
TRLR-7
TRC-8
TRAoD-4
TRL-5
TRA-1

Tthe Spirit
25-05-08, 16:46
TRA- 1

TRL- 2

TRII- 3

TR 4- 4

TR5- 5

TR3- 6

TR1- 7

TRAOD- < - 0... (it doesnt even deserve a zero) :hea:

TombRaiderLover
25-05-08, 16:46
Tomb Raider III - 10/10
Tomb Raider II - 10/10
Tomb Raider - 10/10
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation 10/10

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Very, very difficult to choose between them. They're all equally brilliant.

Now two other very good games, but not quite 10/10.

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Tomb Raider: Chronicles - 9/10
Lara Croft Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness - 9/10

---------------------------------------------------------------------

And then there's Crystal's games. Enjoyable, but they're no masterpieces.

---------------------------------------------------------------------

Lara Croft Tomb Raider: Anniversary - 8/10 (although most levels aren't worth the rating)
Lara Croft Tomb Raider: Legend - 7/10

:wve:

marla_biggs
25-05-08, 17:01
1. TR3 - a great combo of locations and wonderful music
2. TR2
3. legend - a return to form ;)
4. anniversary
5. chronicles
6. angel of darkness - great! but very annoying controls..
7. TR1
8. last revelation - i love the egyptian theme but hate the joint levels :o

those first four are very hard to chose from!

TombRaiderLover
25-05-08, 17:14
1. Tomb Raider 10
2. Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation 9.75
3. Tomb Raider II: Starring Lara Croft 9.5
4. Tomb Raider: Anniversary 9.25
5. Tomb Raider: Legend 9
6. Tomb Raider: Chronicles 8.5
7. Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness 7.5
8. Tomb Raider III: Adventures of Lara Croft 7

:confused: You already posted that list in this thread earlier.

Oh, and TR III last? Blasphemous! :p

AmericanAssassin
25-05-08, 17:20
:confused: You already posted that list in this thread earlier.

Oh, and TR III last? Blasphemous! :p

Oh, well I didn't mean to post twice... :p The thread is a little old and people post these all the time, so I thought it was new. :)

The only aspect of TR3 I like is Sophia Leigh. I really like her, but the game itself just doesn't seem that fun to me...

Drone
25-05-08, 17:24
The only aspect of TR3 I like is Sophia Leigh. I really like her, but the game itself just doesn't seem that fun to me...

Same here. For the same reason I also like the lost artifact

TR93
25-05-08, 17:28
Tomb Raider- 7/10
Tomb Raider 2- 2/10
Tomb Raider 3- 5/10
Tomb Raider 4 TLR- 6/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles-5/10
Tomb Raider AoD-7/10
Tomb Raider Legend-8/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary-9/10

Inkheart
25-05-08, 17:30
TRII - 1
TR - 2
TRIII - 3
TRIV - 4
Anniversary - 5
TRC - 6
Legend - 7
AoD - 8

Azerutan
25-05-08, 17:33
Tomb Raider - 5/5
Tomb Raider II - 5/5
Tomb Raider III - 4/5
Tomb Raider The Last Revelation - 4,5/5
Tomb Raider Chronicles - 4/5
Tomb Raider Angel of Darkness - 3/5
Tomb Raider Legend - 4/5

:)

KC Mraz
25-05-08, 17:35
Tomb Raider: 10
TR Legend: 8.5/9
TR III: 8
TR II: 8
TR The Angel of Darkness: 7
TR Chronicles: 6
TR The Last Revelation: 3


I haven't played Anniversary but with the stuff I've looked it's on the 2nd or 3rd position :).

jarekhanzelka
25-05-08, 17:38
Tr3 - 1
Tr2 - 2
Tr - 3
Traod - 4
Tr4 - 5
Tra - 6
Trc - 7
Trl - 8

TRexbait
26-05-08, 02:06
TR1: 8/10
TR2: 7/10
TR3: 10/10
TR4: 10/10
TRL: 8/10
TRA: 7/10

Those not listed, I do not have... yet.

rowanlim
26-05-08, 04:13
Tr4: 2
Tr5: 5
Aod: 1
Trl: 4
Tra: 3

Trevor_M92
26-05-08, 04:23
1. Tomb Raider II
2. Tomb Raider
3. Tomb Raider III
4. Tomb Raider: Last Revelation
5. Tomb Raider: Anniversary
6. Tomb Raider: Chronicles
7. Tomb Raider: Legend
8. Tomb Raider: Angel of Darkness



Both Tomb Raider 1 and 2 are both tied, but I positioned 2 at the top because that is the one I play most consistantly, not my most favorable since I equally grant 1 and 2 as my top favorite.

marukisu
26-05-08, 04:24
...

MikeAC
26-05-08, 07:03
1) The Last Revelation - 10/10
2) Tomb Raider - 10/10
3) Tomb Raider II - 9/10
4) Tomb Raider III - 7.5/10
5) Anniversary - 4/10
6) AOD and Legend tied - 2/10
7) Chronicles - 1/10

KurtisLonely
26-05-08, 07:08
TRAOD- < - 0... (it doesnt even deserve a zero) :hea:but you ARE working on AoDII? ok, I honestly can't understand that..



to me;
TR1: 10/10
TR2: 09/10
TR3: 07/10
TR4: 06/10 ( < way too bloody much Egypt! )
TR5: 07/10
TR6: 10/10!!!!!!!!!
TR7: 07/10
TRA: 08/10