PDA

View Full Version : Rate each Tomb Raider out of 10


Pages : [1] 2

TRhalloween
02-09-08, 16:39
Tomb Raider: 10/10
Tomb Raider 2: Not Played much yet
Tomb Raider 3: 7/10
Tomb Raider LR: 6.5/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: Not Played much yet
Tomb Raider AoD: 3/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 9/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 3/10

Dia2blo
02-09-08, 16:42
Tomb Raider:9/10
Tomb Raider 2: 8/10
Tomb Raider 3: 10/10
Tomb Raider LR: 9/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 7/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 6/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 7/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 8/10

matrix54
02-09-08, 16:44
1=9/10
2=10/10
3=7/10
TLR=10/10
C=6/10
AOD=8/10(benifit of the doubt)
L=8/10
A=9/10

(couldn't it be out of 5)

Naz2000
02-09-08, 16:45
Tomb Raider I - 7/10
Tomb Raider II - 7.5/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 8/10
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation - 8.5/10
Tomb Raider Chroncles - 7/10
Tomb Raider Angel Of Darkness - 8/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 10/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 8.5/10

:tmb:

Dia2blo
02-09-08, 16:47
Legend 10/10 :yik:

Naz2000
02-09-08, 16:50
Legend 10/10 :yik:

^ Lol yup that's right:D

corey01
02-09-08, 16:52
Tomb Raider- 9/10
Tomb Raider 2- 9/10
Tomb Raider 3- 8/10
LR-10/10
AOD- 9/10
legend- 9/10
Anniversary- 8/10

Death Mask
02-09-08, 16:54
Tomb Raider 1 - 8.5
Tomb Raider 2 - 8.7/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 9.1/10
Tomb Raider TLR - 8.5/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles - 7.2/10
Tomb Raider AOD - 8.3/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 2.0/10 http://www.tombraiderforums.com/images/icons/icon13.gifhttp://www.tombraiderforums.com/images/icons/icon13.gif
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 6.5/10

oocladableeblah
02-09-08, 16:58
Tr1- 10/10
tr2- 10/10
tr3- 10/10
tr4- 10/10
tr5- 8/10
traod- 7/10
trl- 8/10
tra- 8/10

Nemo_91
02-09-08, 17:06
TR1 - 10/10
TR2 - 10/10
TR3 - 10/10
TR TLR - 9/10
Chronicles - 6.5/10
TRAOD - 7.5/10
Legend - 8/10
Anniversary - 7/10

clw
02-09-08, 17:11
tr1 havent played
tr2 in the middle of playing
tr3 8/10
tr4 10/10
tr5 5/10
tr6 8/10
tr7 9/10
anniversary 8/10

Mad Tony
02-09-08, 17:24
TR I - 9/10
TR II - 9/10
TR III - 10/10
TR:LR - 8/10
TR:C - 8/10
TR:AoD - 6/10

Legend of Lara
02-09-08, 18:14
Tomb Raider Ooooooone:
10/10, I still very much enjoy it, just like I did when I was a little kiddy.

Tomb Raider Twooooooooooo:
0/0, haven't played yet. D=

Tomb Raider Thrrrreeeeeeeeee:
8/10, pretty good, but incredibulously hard to figure out.

Tomb Raider Foooooouuuuuur:
9/10
Purdy gosh dang good!

Tomb Raider Fiiiiiiiiiive:
0/0, haven't played yet. D=

Tomb Raider Siiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiixxx:
9/10, I lurves it. It might've just been MGS Lara but it was incredibly enjoyable.

Tomb Raider Seeeeeeeeeeven:
2/10, Do Not Want!

Tomb Raider Eig... err... Anniveeeeeeeeeeersary:
7/10, okay-ish, but NOTHING like the original, and that's no good.

Tomb Raider Uuuuuuuuuuuuunderworld:
10/10, playing it right now. I'm halfway through Thailand. So great! :p

Tombreaper
02-09-08, 18:27
TR I - 10/10

TR II - 10/10

TR III - 10/10

TR TLR - 10/10

TRC - 9/10

TR AOD - 8/10

TR LEGEND - 3/10

TR ANNIVERSARY - 4/10

TR UNDERWORLD - probably 4 out of 10

The Gameboy and cellphone games S**k

Nemo_91
02-09-08, 18:31
Oh come on, Legend wasn't THAT bad...I mean 2-3/10? :confused:

Tombreaper
02-09-08, 18:35
Oh come on, Legend wasn't THAT bad...I mean 2-3/10? :confused:

Legend is a very weak game compared to the originals.

TombRaiderLover
02-09-08, 18:35
tr1 - 10/10
tr2 - 10/10
tr3 - 10/10
tr - tlr - 10/10
trc - 9/10
tr - aod - 9/10
trl - 7/10
tra - 8/10

;)

Aurelien52
02-09-08, 18:37
TR1 - 9/10 Such a classic :tmb:
TR2 - 8/10 :tmb:
TR3 - 7/10 Very nice places :hug:
TR4 - 10/10 Long, Hard, And Egypt :tmb:
TR5 - 7/10 Short, but still acceptable :)
TR6 - 6/10 Not finished :hea:
TR7 - 6/10 Really too short...
TRA - 6/10 As Boring as the rain... :D

Legend of Lara
02-09-08, 18:38
Legend is a very weak game compared to the originals.

Precisely. I played Legend with endless expectations in mind. I thought it'd be the grand return of Lara, but instead got a watered down quick thrill ride that felt like half a game. As a Tomb Raider, that's no good.

TombRaiderLover
02-09-08, 18:39
Precisely. I played Legend with endless expectations in mind. I thought it'd be the grand return of Lara, but instead got a watered down quick thrill ride that felt like half a game. As a Tomb Raider, that's no good.

Shame on you for having never played the masterpiece that is Tomb Raider II :p

Rivendell
02-09-08, 18:42
Tomb Raider: 9/10
Tomb Raider 2: 8/10
Tomb Raider 3: 8/10
Tomb Raider 4: 9/10
Tomb Raider 5: 5/10
Tomb Raider 6: 6.5/10
legend: 4 / 10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 6.5/10

:wve:

da tomb raider!
02-09-08, 18:48
Tomb Raider: 10/10
Tomb Raider II: 9/10
Tomb Raider III: 10/10
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation: 9/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 10/10
Lara Croft Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness: 9/10
Lara Croft Tomb Raider: Legend: 4/10
Lara Croft Tomb Raider: Anniversary: 2/10

sandra croft
02-09-08, 18:58
Tomb Raider: 10/10
Tomb Raider II: 10/10
Tomb Raider III: 9.5/10
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation: 8.5/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 8.5/10
Lara Croft Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness: 7.5/10
Lara Croft Tomb Raider: Legend: 8.5/10
Lara Croft Tomb Raider: Anniversary: 8/10

TombRaiderCool
02-09-08, 19:00
Tomb Raider: 8/10
Tomb Raider II: 8.5/10
Tomb Raider III: 9/10
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation: 8/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 7/10
Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness: 7.5/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 9/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 8/10
Tomb Raider Underworld: 10/10
:wve:

remote91
02-09-08, 19:04
TR I - 9/10
TR II - 8/10
TR III - 9/10
TR:LR - 9/10
TR:C - 8/10
TR:AoD - 7/10
TR:Legend - 3/10
TR:A - 6/10

Megalith
02-09-08, 19:09
Tr-10/10
tr2-10/10
tr3-10/10
tr4-9/10
tr5-9/10
tr:aod-6/10
trl-8/10
tra-7/10

b0bb13
02-09-08, 19:27
Tomb Raider The Atlantean Scion - 9.9/10
Tomb Raider The Dagger Of Xian - 10/10
Tomb Raider The Adventures Of Lara Croft - 8/10
Tomb Raider The Last Revelation - 9.5/10
Tomb Raider Chronichles - 8/10
Tomb Raider Angel Of Darkness - 9/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 100/10:cln:
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 9/10

We'll have to see how good Underworld will be,but heck!
Tomb Raider Underworld - 10/10
:p

2kool4u
02-09-08, 19:52
Tr1-10/10
tr2-10/10
tr3-10/10
tr4-10/10
tr5-6/10
tr6-2/10
tr7-8/10
tra-9/10

dizzydoil
02-09-08, 19:55
10/10.

.. for all of them. :p

Marianna12
02-09-08, 20:15
I've only played TR2, AOD, Legend+Anni

TR2: (I haven't played it too much) 6/10
AOD: 8/10
Legend: 10/10
Anniversary: 9/10 (Kinda hard...)

Tyrannosaurus
02-09-08, 20:16
TR1 - 9/10
TR2 - 9/10
TR3 - 7/10
TR4 - 10/10
TR5 - 6/10
TR AOD - haven't played
TRL - haven't played
TRA - haven't played
TRU - haven't played

Marianna12
02-09-08, 20:16
TR I - 9/10
TR II - 8/10
TR III - 9/10
TR:LR - 9/10
TR:C - 8/10
TR:AoD - 7/10
TR:Legend - 3/10
TR:A - 6/10

Why Legend 3/10?????????? That game was awesome!!!!!

b0bb13
02-09-08, 20:19
I've only played TR2, AOD, Legend+Anni

TR2: (I haven't played it too much) 6/10
AOD: 8/10
Legend: 10/10
Anniversary: 9/10 (Kinda hard...)

Why Legend 3/10?????????? That game was awesome!!!!!

http://i.pbase.com/o4/98/583898/1/63713938.qaEEdjG9.popcorn.gif

clw
02-09-08, 20:32
bobb i dont understand that post but the little guy eating popcorn really amused me and Tyrannosaurus you should try the new games change is sometimes good

b0bb13
02-09-08, 20:35
bobb i dont understand that post but the little guy eating popcorn really amused me and Tyrannosaurus you should try the new games change is sometimes good

Lol!:D
I posted that because when I also registered here,one of my first comments was about Legend and how awesome it is.....and I was assaulted by the Core fanboys,so now it's my turn to watch,I guess.:vlol::p

clw
02-09-08, 20:40
ok ive still got a smile on my face, its wierd that people dont like the new ones the only tr game i didnt like was chronicles

sandra croft
02-09-08, 20:47
Tomb Raider I - 7/10
Tomb Raider II - 7.5/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 8/10
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation - 8.5/10
Tomb Raider Chroncles - 7/10
Tomb Raider Angel Of Darkness - 8/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 10/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 8.5/10

:tmb:

Tomb Raider 1 7/10 :yik: and AOD gets 8/10 :confused:

Mad Tony
02-09-08, 20:57
Why Legend 3/10?????????? That game was awesome!!!!!Some people don't like Legend, including me.

Ward Dragon
02-09-08, 20:59
TR1: 9/10
TR2: 8/10
TR3: 9/10
TR4: 7/10
TR5: 7/10
AOD: 7/10
Legend: 4/10 (raised to 6/10 for next-gen mode with voice volume off)
TRA: 8/10

Scores subject to change pending replay of the games :p (I haven't played through the classics in a long time because I like to wait until I forget the level design so I can enjoy it more. I think it's time to replay them very soon.)

Samsdad
02-09-08, 21:15
TR1 8/10 very innovative for its time but an easy game overall
TR2 9/10 Core began to really hit their stride
TR3 10/10 definately the best in Core's series
TR4 7/10
TR5 6/10 really became more of the same
AOD 7/10 You could tell that Core had reached their level of incompetence but they gave it a good try

TRL 8/10 Fun was back in TR games but it was short and easy
TRA 9/10 CD is beginning to learn but erred a little too much in makking puzzles a more button manipulation than a cerebral exercise

TRU ?

James_Rutland
02-09-08, 21:32
Tr1 10/10
tr2 10/10
tr3 10/10
tr4 9/10
tr5 8/10
tr6 7/10
tr7 6/10
tra 8/10

tranniversary119
02-09-08, 21:34
I find it hilarious some of the unfair scores Legend and Anniversary are getting. I understand it's your opinion but it's more of a joke than an opinion :rolleyes:
TR1- 10/10
TR2- 9/10
TR3- 9/10
TR4- 8/10
TRC- 6/10
TRAOD- 6/10
TRLEGEND-8/10
TRANNIVERSARY- 8.5/10
TRUNDERWORLD- From what I've seen 9/10
See that's fair scoring right there.. 2-4/10 for Legend come on!

KIKO
02-09-08, 21:35
TR1 10/10 Really good game
TR2 10/10 My favourite and good too
TR3 7/10 Sorry but the gameplay is the same as the previous, the same thing.
TR4 8/10 Good story but gameplay is the same, and oh that horrible level backtracking
TR5 5/10 Again same gameplay, poor story.
TR6 4/10 Good story, hate Kurtis, hate rpg, gameplay is boring and it doesn't look like the police is chasing Lara.
TR7 5/10 Hollywood Story, Good gameplay, short, easy, linear, lack of silence.
TRA 7/10 Good gameplay, 7h long, not hard but not easy, perfect isolation, emo Lara, linear.

xXhayleyroxXx
02-09-08, 21:38
tr1- 8/10
tr2-8/10
tr3- 6/10
tr4- never played
trc-7/10
aod-8/10
legend-10/10
anniversary- 10/10

whats with all the hating legend and anniversary! im in love with them XD

mctronken
02-09-08, 21:39
Tomb Raider: 9
Tomb Raider 2: 8
Tomb Raider 3: 8
Tomb Raider LR: 9
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 6
Tomb Raider AoD: 7
Tomb Raider Legend: 10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 7 <- Could have been 10 with next gen mode

Christi
02-09-08, 21:41
TRI - 10/10
TRII - 9/10
TRIII - 9/10
TRIV - 10/10
TRV - 8/10
TRVI - 8/10
TRL - 4/10
TRA - 6.5/10
TRU - 9.5/10 (right now) ;)

moodydog
02-09-08, 22:16
judging you know the score:

10
9
10
6
5
3
9.5
9
TRU approx 10!!!!! :jmp:

:BitterSweet:
02-09-08, 23:00
TR 1 - 8.5/10
TR 2 - 9/10
TR 3 - 9/10
TR:LR - (Haven't really played.)
TR:C - 7/10
TR:AOD - 7/10
TR:L - 9.5/10
TR:A - 6.5/10
TR:U - 10/10!

:wve:

hera7days
02-09-08, 23:08
TR1 - 10/10
TR2 - 9/10
TR3 - 8/10
TRLR - 7/10
TRC - 6/10
TRAOD - 10/10
TRL - 7 or 8/10, depending on my mood
Haven't played TRA

TRexbait
02-09-08, 23:45
TR1: 9/10
TR2:8/10
\TR3: 10/10
TR4: 10/10
TRC: Don't have yet.
TRAOD: 10000000000000000000000000000000000000000/10
TRL: 9/10 The more i play it, the more i like it. :D
TRA: 6/10 Not that great. :(

KIKO
02-09-08, 23:48
It's interesting how the new fans care more about the graphics than the gameplay. Some even refuse to play classics because of the horrible graphics, I'm not telling that it's you but for example my other cousin, he's like "No way, with those graphics never" He and some more just don't know what they are missing ;)

b0bb13
03-09-08, 00:06
It's interesting how the new fans care more about the graphics than the gameplay. Some even refuse to play classics because of the horrible graphics, I'm not telling that it's you but for example my other cousin, he's like "No way, with those graphics never" He and some more just don't know what they are missing ;)

So true and sad.But even more sad is when they get stuck in Legend or Anniversary,or they say that it's too hard for them.I feel like shouting 'ZOMFG!Are you total retards?!',but I don't because I'm well-mannered,lol.:p
Anyway,Legend FTW!:ohn::ton:

KIKO
03-09-08, 00:11
So true and sad.But even more sad is when they get stuck in Legend or Anniversary,or they say that it's too hard for them.I feel like shouting 'ZOMFG!Are you total retards?!',but I don't because I'm well-mannered,lol.:p
Anyway,Legend FTW!:ohn::ton:

Legend and Anniversary seem like a test for the new fans to test how hard they find the games, and if they get stuck and check a forum to see how an hardcore fan says them the game difficulty, around 10 out of 100. Sorry but it's true. Legend is too easy, what makes it annoying is Lara being knocked down every now and then.

b0bb13
03-09-08, 00:16
Legend and Anniversary seem like a test for the new fans to test how hard they find the games, and if they get stuck and check a forum to see how an hardcore fan says them the game difficulty, around 10 out of 100. Sorry but it's true. Legend is too easy, what makes it annoying is Lara being knocked down every now and then.

I think that Legend was a tech demo,to see if people were still interested in the series.Anniversary already started to be a little bit more like the classics,since it didn't so much shooting.Legend is very easy,but it's so much fun!:D
And yeah,I was hoping they'd fix that.It was ok in Anni,since you could make Lara do an 'escape' so that she won't fall.Hope it's back in TRU.:)

KC Mraz
03-09-08, 00:42
TR1 - 10/10
TRII - 9.7/10
TRIII - 9/10
TLR - 8.5/10
Chonicles - 8/10
AOD - 8/10
Legend - 9/10 (it'd be 10, but the 2nd bike sequence is long as hell :pi:)
Anni - 9/10
Underworld 10/10 and you know it will be :ohn:

Ward Dragon
03-09-08, 01:04
I find it hilarious some of the unfair scores Legend and Anniversary are getting. I understand it's your opinion but it's more of a joke than an opinion :rolleyes:

Thank you for that :rolleyes: I happen to think Legend was a joke of a game, so I guess it evens out.

Anajrob
03-09-08, 01:23
TR1 10/10
TR2 7/10
TR3 9/10
TR4 7/10
TRC 5/10
AOD 8/10
TRL 4/10
TRA 5/10

I guess...

Tihocan9
03-09-08, 02:08
I would give them all 10/10 because I honestly love them all but I will be tough to give a fair scoring.

Tomb Raider I- 9/10
Tomb Raider 2-9/10
Tomb Raider 3- 10/10 perfect
Tomb Raider 4- 9.5/10 (from what I have played it is pretty excellent)
Tomb Raider Chronicles: Haven't Played enough to score
Tomb Raider AOD: 8/10 Great game but things here and there that bugged me
Tomb Raider Legend 7.5/10 Great game but far to easy for Tomb Raider
Tomb Raider Anniversary 8.5/10 Great game and regained the Tomb Raider spirit

I am hoping that TRU will get a 10/10 from me but who knows :D

LaraCroft90
03-09-08, 02:21
Tomb Raider 1 - 10 out of 10 - I love to kill Natla!
Tomb Raider 2 - 9.1 out of 10 - I like it!
Tomb Raider 3 - 9.9 out of 10 - I love the locations!
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation - 9.0 out of 10 - Hard, but good!
Tomb Raider: Chronicles - 8.9 out of 10 - A little stressing, yet good!
Tomb Raider: Angel of Darkness - 7.9 out of 10 - Dissapointed me...
Tomb Raider: Legend - 9.8 out of 10 - Nice return, Lara!
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 9.9 out of 10 - Almost a master piece!

Gold Series

Tomb Raider:Unfinished Business - 8.0 out of 10 - Harder than TR1
Tomb Raider: Golden Mask - 9.5 out of 10 - I love it!
Tomb Raider: The Lost Artifact - 10 out of 10 - Perfect!

Gameboy Series

Tomb Raider - 8.5 out of 10 - Good for Gameboy Color
Tomb Raider the Curse of the Sword - 9.7 out of 10 - I love it
Tomb Raider - The Prophecy - 9.9 out of 10 - Very good!

takamotosan
03-09-08, 02:39
Tr1: 9.5/10
TR2: 9/10
TR3: 8.5/10
TRLR: 8/10
TRC: 6/10
TRAOD: 8/10
TRL: 7/10
TRA: 8/10

Yuna´s Wish
03-09-08, 02:43
Tomb Raider: 9.5/10
Tomb Raider 2: 9/10
Tomb Raider 3: 8.5/10
The Last Revelation: 7.5/10
Chronicles: 4/10
Angel of Darkness: 8/10
Legend: 8.25/10
Anniversary: 9.5/10

CatyCroft
03-09-08, 03:05
TR1 - 8.5/10
TR2 - 9/10
TR3 - 9.5/10
TR4 - 7/10
TR5 - 7/10
TRAOD - 6.5/10
TRL - 10/10
TRA - 9.5/10

:wve:

BorntoRun
03-09-08, 03:23
TR 1: 10/10
Unfinished Business: 10/10
Shadow of the Cat: 10/10
TR 2: 9/10
TR 3: 9/10
Last Revelation: 2/10
Chronicles... Let's not discuss Chronicles.
Anniversary: 8/10

Fallen.Angel
03-09-08, 03:32
TR 1 - 8.5/10
TR 2 - 10/10
TR 3 - 9/10
TR 4 [The Last Revelation] - 8/10
TR 5 [Chronicles] - 6/10
TR 6 [AOD] - 8/10
TR 7 [LEGEND] - 8/10
TR Anniversary - 9/10

As for Underworld, I KNOW it's going to be a 10/10 for me.

Olabelle
03-09-08, 03:58
TR 1 - 10/10

TR 2 - 9/10

TR 3 - 9/10

TR Last Revelation - 10/10

TR Chronicles - 1/10

TR AOD - 2/10

TR Legend - 3/10

TR Anniversary - 6/10

TR Underworld - 5/10 (I hope I get proved wrong, but I'm losing faith in CD)

violentblossom
03-09-08, 04:48
Tomb Raider Uuuuuuuuuuuuunderworld:
10/10, playing it right now. I'm halfway through Thailand. So great! :p

how the heck....?

also, i'm wondering why on EARTH Legend and Anniversary ranked so poorly.

yes, the levels on Legend were linear, and quite a bit easier, and then there were the annoyances of Zip and Alister, but 2/10 just seems bitter, lol. i don't get it.. i don't think they were THAT bad. Anniversary's atmosphere wasn't as frightening as the original, but to me, that doesn't warrant such a heinous score.

Mad Tony
03-09-08, 06:12
I don't know why some people get in such an uproar when somebody says they don't like Anniversary or Legend and gives it a low score.

xXhayleyroxXx
03-09-08, 07:38
It's interesting how the new fans care more about the graphics than the gameplay. Some even refuse to play classics because of the horrible graphics, I'm not telling that it's you but for example my other cousin, he's like "No way, with those graphics never" He and some more just don't know what they are missing ;)

im gonna be honest and say im actually scared of most of the levels on the earlier games, but i still love them. and even though i love the more recent ones, i've grown up with tomb raider and iv watched her progress as i have, and i do still play on those games XD
and my best friend isnt really into tomb raider, but she chose tr1 to pay on yesterdey :)
xxxxxxxxxxx

Kiss-Bite
03-09-08, 08:12
Tomb Raider - 10/10
Tomb Raider 2 - 10/10 (I love this game!):D
Tomb Raider 3 - 10/10
Tomb Raider LR - 10/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles - 7/10
Tomb Raider AOD - 7/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 8/10 (Really liked it but far too short!):(
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 8/10

Tomb Raider Underworld - Hoping it's going to be high, will it get a 10/10?!;)

billbo
03-09-08, 08:22
My best are in this order

*Tomb Raider 2 = Best ever tr game
*Tomb Raider Legend = Really Enjoyable
*Tomb Raider = Stayed up until 2 am working out swiches and keys + its the first ever TR game!!!!
*Tomb Raider Chronicles = Plenty of variety and loved levels like Red alert
*Tomb Raider Anniversary = Found it a bit hard and was a bit boring
*Tomb Raider Last Revelation = Loved the jeeps e.t.c but got bored by the end. (PS What abt the sad ending:()
*Tomb Raider 3 = never really played it
*Tomb Raider Angel of Darkenss = Utter rubbish and i hated it. so pointless and completly the opposite of what TR is

So yea :D

tombraiderluka
03-09-08, 08:23
Tomb Raider: 9/10
Tomb Raider 2: 9/10
Tomb Raider 3: 10/10
The Last Revelation: 8/10
Chronicles: 7/10
Angel of Darkness: 7/10
Legend: 8/10
Anniversary: 9/10

chakotay1
03-09-08, 09:58
TR1 - 9/10

TR2 - 10/10

TR3 - 7/10

TR4 - 4/10

TR5 - 00000.5/10

TR6 - I wouldn't play that bug ridden joke that has no right to even be called TR crap fest if you payed me!

LEGEND - 9.5/10

anniversary 9/10

to everyone who gave legend and anny low score get a grip! they saved the series! after the complete disasters core brought out! How can some of you give AoD 9/10 WTF! So you like playing games thaty are full of bugs crap camera angles and totally crap controlls? eh?

billbo
03-09-08, 11:06
:jmp: Exactly couldnt agree with you more on that 1. Any one who has even given it 1 out of 10 is mad:hea:

tidusffxwakka
03-09-08, 11:12
Tomb Raider: 6/10
Tomb Raider 2: 9/10
Tomb Raider 3: 7/10
Tomb Raider LR: 6/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 6/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 5/10 thou did like its story maybe 7/10 for story but too buggy for me an horrid controls
Tomb Raider Legend: 8/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 9/10

Night Crawler
03-09-08, 11:14
Tomb Raider: 7/10
Tomb Raider 2: 8/10
Tomb Raider 3: 4/10
Tomb Raider LR: 10/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 5/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 1/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 7/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 8/10

tombraider123
03-09-08, 11:28
Tomb Raider - 10/10
Tomb Raider 2 - 7/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 8/10
The Last Revelation - 9/10
Chronicles - 7/10
Angel of Darkness - 9.5/10
Legend - 8.5/10
Anniversary - 8/10

Ariel
03-09-08, 12:11
Tomb Raider:8/10
Tomb Raider 2: 7/10
Tomb Raider 3: 9/10
Tomb Raider LR: 10/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 5/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 6/10 (would be higher if the game wouldn't crash on me so many times)
Tomb Raider Legend: 10/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 10/10

Smog
03-09-08, 12:29
Tomb Raider: 10/10
Tomb Raider 2: 8/10
Tomb Raider 3: 9/10
Tomb Raider TLR: 7/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 5/10
Tomb Raider AOD: 5/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 7/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 9/10

Titanium
03-09-08, 12:57
From the ones I have played enough.

TR2 - 8/10
TR2G - 6/10
TRLR - 9/10
TRC - 7/10
TRAOD - 8/10
TRL - 6/10
TRA - 6.5/10

Angelus
03-09-08, 12:59
TR 1 - 8/10
TR 2 - 9/10
TR 3 - 6/10
TR 4 - 8/10
TR 5 - 10/10
TR: AoD - 4/10
TR: Legend - 6/10
TR Anniversary - 7.5/10

:)

Larapink
03-09-08, 14:31
Tomb Raider 1 - 9/10
Tomb Raider 2 - 9/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 8/10
Tomb Raider 4 - THE LAST REVELATION - 7.5/10
Tomb Raider 5 - CHRONICLES - 8.9/10
Tomb Radier 6 - AOD - 0/10 (I lost interest in Tomb Raider for a little while after this game)
Tomb Raider 7 - LEGEND - 9.9/10 (The game that made me love Tomb Raider again. :jmp:)
Tomb Raider - ANNIVERSARY - 9.8/10

UNDERWORLD, will be a 10/10 from me. :jmp:

Lenochka
03-09-08, 14:34
Tr1 - 10/10
tr2- 9/10
tr3 - 8/10
tr4 - 7/10
tr5 - 6/10
tr:aod - 5/10 (the only reason I gave it any points was because Janice made her grand debut in this title. xD )
tr:l - 9/10
tr:a - 9/10

TRhalloween
03-09-08, 15:51
TR1 10/10 Really good game
TR2 10/10 My favourite and good too
TR3 7/10 Sorry but the gameplay is the same as the previous, the same thing.
TR4 8/10 Good story but gameplay is the same, and oh that horrible level backtracking
TR5 5/10 Again same gameplay, poor story.
TR6 4/10 Good story, hate Kurtis, hate rpg, gameplay is boring and it doesn't look like the police is chasing Lara.
TR7 5/10 Hollywood Story, Good gameplay, short, easy, linear, lack of silence.
TRA 7/10 Good gameplay, 7h long, not hard but not easy, perfect isolation, emo Lara, linear.

I definitely think Angel was a bit too RPG and Legend was too short and easy but "emo Lara"?

Flame
03-09-08, 16:03
Tomb Raider I - 7/10
Tomb Raider II - 7.5/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 8/10
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation - 8.5/10
Tomb Raider Chroncles - 7/10
Tomb Raider Angel Of Darkness - 8/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 10/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 8.5/10

:tmb:

So there's absoulty no way Legend could have improved then ;P

Tomb Raider - 9/10
Tomb Raider 2 - 9.5/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 9
Tomb Raider 4 - 7.5
Tomb Raider 5 - 8/10
Tomb Raider Angel of Darkness - 8.5/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 6/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 9/10

Lee croft
03-09-08, 16:16
tomb raider 1 - 6 / 10
tomb raider 2 - 7/ 10
tomb raider 3- 10/ 10
tomb raider last revelation - 3/ 10
tomb raider chornicles - 10/10
tomb raider angel of darkness - 5/ 10
tomb raider legend - 10/ 10
tomb raider anniversary - 10/ 10

Deamonella
03-09-08, 17:05
Tomb Raider I 7/10
Tomb Raider II 10/10
Tomb Raider III 9/10
Tomb Raider IV 2/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles 5/10
Tomb Raider AOD 6/10
Tomb Raider Legend 10/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary 9/10

Mad Tony
03-09-08, 17:08
I definitely think Angel was a bit too RPG and Legend was too short and easy but "emo Lara"?"WHERE! IS! MY! MOTHER!?"

I rest my case :p

robm_2007
03-09-08, 17:08
Tomb Raider: 8/10
Tomb Raider 2: 10/10
Tomb Raider 3: 9/10
Tomb Raider LR: 9/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: never played
Tomb Raider AoD: 10/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 6/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 7/10

RAID
03-09-08, 17:28
Tomb Raider: 8/10
Tomb Raider 2: 9/10
Tomb Raider 3: 10/10
Tomb Raider LR: 8/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 5/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 3/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 7/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 2/10

Survival
03-09-08, 17:55
Tomb Raider - 8/10
Tomb Raider 2 - 6/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 8/10
Tomb Raider 4 - 10/10
Tomb Raider 5 - 5/10
Tomb Raider Angel of Darkness - 10/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 4/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 5/10

domina
03-09-08, 18:19
"WHERE! IS! MY! MOTHER!?"

I rest my case :p

Emo kids don't care about their parents. :p Amanda looked and acted more like an emo kid.


As for the ratings...

TRI - 8/10
TRII - 9/10
TRIII - 6/10
TLR - 8/10
TRV - 4/10
AOD - 3/10 (Could never bring myself to finish)
TRL - 8/10
TRA - 7/10

TR GBC - 8/10
Curse of the Sword - 6/10

Lemmie
03-09-08, 18:21
TR - 7.5/10
TR2 - 8/10
TR3 - 9/10
TRLR - 9/10
TRC - 6/10
AOD - 4.75/10
Legend - 8/10
Anniversary - 8.75/10

filthylostsoul
03-09-08, 18:41
Tomb Raider: 9/10
Tomb Raider II: 10/10
Tomb Raider III: 9/10
Tomb Raider TLR: 7/10
Tomb Raider C: 6/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 2/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 8/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary 8/10


:)

Domino
03-09-08, 18:51
TR1: ----
TR2: ----
TR3: ----
TR4: ----
TRC: ----
TR6: ----
TR7: 6/10
TRA: 5/10

I do own the Classics but haven't completed any so I'm not voting until I do!

Smog
03-09-08, 19:23
I do own the Classics but haven't completed any so I'm not voting until I do!

Then what are you doing here? Go and play them! Now! :D

TRhalloween
03-09-08, 19:29
TR1: ----
TR2: ----
TR3: ----
TR4: ----
TRC: ----
TR6: ----
TR7: 6/10
TRA: 5/10

I do own the Classics but haven't completed any so I'm not voting until I do!

I haven't completed them either but I still voted.

AmericanAssassin
03-09-08, 19:58
TR1 10
TR2 9.5
TR3 7.5
TLR 9.5
TRC 8.5
AOD 8
TRL 8.5
TRA 8.5

I'm a tad biased. :whi:

Angelus
03-09-08, 20:23
"WHERE! IS! MY! MOTHER!?"

I rest my case :p

Yeah, that's sooo emo.

Lenochka
03-09-08, 22:29
Emo kids don't care about their parents.
Exactly :tmb:

AOD Lara was the queen of emo, that blood on her hands in VC's apartment was most likely from all the cutting xD

Ward Dragon
03-09-08, 22:39
Exactly :tmb:

AOD Lara was the queen of emo, that blood on her hands in VC's apartment was most likely from all the cutting xD

AOD Lara wasn't emo at all. She was just a ***** who spoke with really weird emphasis for most of her lines :vlol:

TRA Lara was much more emo (basically from the Larson scene in Natla's Mines onwards...). She couldn't control herself, then had a massive freak-out regretting what she did, nearly got herself killed by Kold because she was too emotional to think properly, then got totally talked into circles by Natla due to her emotional vulnerabilities, finally deciding to just shoot stuff to make it stop :p

Rivendell
03-09-08, 22:41
TRA Lara was much more emo (basically from the Larson scene in Natla's Mines onwards...). She couldn't control herself, then had a massive freak-out regretting what she did, nearly got herself killed by Kold because she was too emotional to think properly, then got totally talked into circles by Natla due to her emotional vulnerabilities, finally deciding to just shoot stuff to make it stop :p

:vlol:
If only she'd maintained her persona from her 'Interrogating Larson' scene. I love everything about that scene, the way she talks, her actions - perfect! :tmb:

Ward Dragon
03-09-08, 22:44
:vlol:
If only she'd maintained her persona from her 'Interrogating Larson' scene. I love everything about that scene, the way she talks, her actions - perfect! :tmb:

I know! She was perfect in that cutscene (and Larson was awesome too :p). If they had just maintained that personality throughout the game it would have been so much better.

Rivendell
03-09-08, 22:46
After she'd killed Larson, I really thought she was just going to bend down and pluck the fuse out of his hands, and walk off, satisfied.
Even that would've been better than her re-enactment of Macbeth.

Ward Dragon
03-09-08, 22:49
After she'd killed Larson, I really thought she was just going to bend down and pluck the fuse out of his hands, and walk off, satisfied.
Even that would've been better than her re-enactment of Macbeth.

I absolutely hate the way that she shot Larson (she seemed so weak and insecure, like she had no reason to shoot him other than to prove to herself that Larson was wrong about knowing her personality). I wouldn't have liked that scene even if her reaction afterwards was different, and if Lara had acted like her weakness was a good thing then I might have hated it even more.

They should have just had Larson shoot at her first, no questions asked, and then had her walk off afterwards as you described. That would have been so much better.

Tyrannosaurus
03-09-08, 22:58
bobb i dont understand that post but the little guy eating popcorn really amused me and Tyrannosaurus you should try the new games change is sometimes good

I'd like to, but I have neither a computer sufficiently new enough, an appropriate console system, or the time and funds necessary to consider either option.

But when I do, I'll surely play them, along with a long list of other games I've been missing in the past 6 years or so.

BorntoRun
04-09-08, 03:05
How come no one else rated The Gold games? Or at least one of them. Also, I forgot TR 2 and 3 Gold.

TR II Gold: 8/10
TR III Gold: 7/10

chakotay1
04-09-08, 09:33
From the ones I have played enough.

TR2 - 8/10
TR2G - 6/10
TRLR - 9/10
TRC - 7/10
TRAOD - 8/10
TRL - 6/10
TRA - 6.5/10

Titanium AoD 8/10???!!!:confused::confused::confused: It was the biggest mess of a game ever created! So you like playing games with HORRIBLE CONTROLLS, bugs every 5 seconds and crashing on you constantly fine by me but for me personally no thank you! I even refused to buy it for £3 from Blockbusters because I have talked to guys who say it was beyond redemption! Listen the game was so bad it cost Core thier existance!

Legend 6/10 :confused: 9/10! CD revived and brought about a much needed kick up the pants and a breath of fresh air to a series I had lost all faith for after TR4!

sam_raider_05
04-09-08, 10:37
Tomb Raider - 9/10
Tomb Raider II - 9/10
Tomb Raider III - 8/10
Tomb Raider TLR - 8/10
TR Chronicles - 6/10
Tomb Raider AOD - 3/10
TR Legend - 8/10
TR Anniversary - 9/10

Rivendell
04-09-08, 10:58
Titanium AoD 8/10???!!!:confused::confused::confused: It was the biggest mess of a game ever created! So you like playing games with HORRIBLE CONTROLLS, bugs every 5 seconds and crashing on you constantly fine by me but for me personally no thank you! I even refused to buy it for £3 from Blockbusters because I have talked to guys who say it was beyond redemption! Listen the game was so bad it cost Core thier existance!

Legend 6/10 :confused: 9/10! CD revived and brought about a much needed kick up the pants and a breath of fresh air to a series I had lost all faith for after TR4!

I guess Titanium has his own opinion. :wve:

Survival
04-09-08, 11:01
Titanium AoD 8/10???!!!:confused::confused::confused: It was the biggest mess of a game ever created! So you like playing games with HORRIBLE CONTROLLS, bugs every 5 seconds and crashing on you constantly fine by me but for me personally no thank you! I even refused to buy it for £3 from Blockbusters because I have talked to guys who say it was beyond redemption! Listen the game was so bad it cost Core thier existance!

Legend 6/10 :confused: 9/10! CD revived and brought about a much needed kick up the pants and a breath of fresh air to a series I had lost all faith for after TR4!

That is YOUR opinion. Titanium has the right to have one of his own ;)

Rivendell
04-09-08, 11:11
That is YOUR opinion. Titanium has the right to have one of his own ;)

Re-reading Chakotay's post, it doesn't seem like he's even played TR6. Which is a shame really, because people should really give things a chance themselves before spouting off the negative side of other people's opinions.

Titanium
04-09-08, 11:20
Titanium AoD 8/10???!!!:confused::confused::confused: It was the biggest mess of a game ever created! So you like playing games with HORRIBLE CONTROLLS, bugs every 5 seconds and crashing on you constantly fine by me but for me personally no thank you! I even refused to buy it for £3 from Blockbusters because I have talked to guys who say it was beyond redemption! Listen the game was so bad it cost Core thier existance!

Legend 6/10 :confused: 9/10! CD revived and brought about a much needed kick up the pants and a breath of fresh air to a series I had lost all faith for after TR4!

Although it was heavily criticised, badly controlled, buggy. I got around all of them and enjoyed the game.

Legend was ridiculously short compared to AOD and the storyline wasnt as interesting. They turned Lara from a cold hard Tomb Raider into a delicate emo thing!

Lara: (Every 5 seconds) Mother! :(

Heckler
04-09-08, 11:32
1. 8
2. 10
3. 10
4. 6
5. 6
AOD. -10000000
Legend. 9
Anniv. 10

Sedge
04-09-08, 11:38
Hmm, by the enjoyment level I guess..

TR: 9/10 (never got into Atlantis though)
TR2: ?/10
TR3: 6/10 (never got into Antarctica though)
TRLR: 10/10 (:D)
TRC: ?/10
TRAOD: ?/10
TRL: 7/10
TRA: 8/10

Larapink
04-09-08, 15:25
To get back on topic.:whi:
Tomb Raider 1 - 9/10
Tomb Raider 2 - 9/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 8/10
Tomb Raider 4 - THE LAST REVELATION - 7.5/10
Tomb Raider 5 - CHRONICLES - 8.9/10
Tomb Radier 6 - AOD - 0/10 (I lost interest in Tomb Raider for a little while after this game)
Tomb Raider 7 - LEGEND - 9.9/10 (The game that made me love Tomb Raider again. :jmp:)
Tomb Raider - ANNIVERSARY - 9.8/10

UNDERWORLD, will be a 10/10 from me. :jmp:

MadCroy101
04-09-08, 15:41
Tomb Raider: 9.3/10
Tomb Raider 2: 8.1/10
Tomb Raider 3: 9.8/10
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation: 10/10
Tomb Riader: Chronicles: 7.9/10
Tomb Raider: Angel of Darkness: 9.1/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 4.1/10 :mad: :smk: (Why, Crystal?)
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 8.5/10

Legend is the worst........ :wve:

KC Mraz
04-09-08, 15:44
tr:aod - 5/10 (the only reason I gave it any points was because Janice made her grand debut in this title. xD )

I know! AoD deserves to be nominated to a GOTY award just because of Janice :D
GOTY = Game of the year

coolezpunk
05-09-08, 00:02
TR1 - 10/10
TR2 - 9/10
TR3 - 10/10
TRLR - 8.9/10
TRC - 8.8/10
AoD - 11/10 :tmb:
TRL - negative infinity/10
TRA - 8/10

:wve:

Melonie Tomb Raider
05-09-08, 00:47
TR1: 8

TR2: 7

TR3: 7.5

TR4: 6.5

TR5: 6

TR6: 5

TR7: 7

TRA: 7

Brutally honest opinions. :p

b0bb13
05-09-08, 01:01
I know! AoD deserves to be nominated to a GOTY award just because of Janice :D
GOTY = Game of the year

I gave AOD a 9 because Janice is a 10(duh!) and AoD an 8.:D

TR1: 8

TR2: 7

TR3: 7.5

TR4: 6.5

TR5: 6

TR6: 5

TR7: 7

TRA: 7

Brutally honest opinions. :p

And you still have the courage to call yourself Meloine Tomb Raider?:rolleyes:
:vlol:j/k:p

Lenochka
05-09-08, 01:08
I know! AoD deserves to be nominated to a GOTY award just because of Janice :D
GOTY = Game of the year

Indeed, Janice has been really busy dealing with the massive amounts of fame she received from her role in AOD, she should find some time to get her own game in the works. :D

TR FAN 18
05-09-08, 08:20
TR1: 9/10
TR2: 9/10
TR3: 10/10
TRLR: 10/10
TRC: 6.5/10
TR AOD: 6/10
TRL: 5/10 (Why so short?! :hea:)
TRA: 7.5/10 (Not as good as the original)

young Lara Croft
05-09-08, 08:28
TR1-8
TR2-9
TR3-9
TR4-9
TR5-8
TR AoD-8
TRL-7
TRA-6

chakotay1
05-09-08, 08:33
Although it was heavily criticised, badly controlled, buggy. I got around all of them and enjoyed the game.

Legend was ridiculously short compared to AOD and the storyline wasnt as interesting. They turned Lara from a cold hard Tomb Raider into a delicate emo thing!

Lara: (Every 5 seconds) Mother! :(

No Titanium CRYSTAL DYNAMICS RESTORED THE SERIES AFTER THE TERRIBLE CRAP THAT WAS 5 AND AoD!! The reason it was short was because they were trying a new game engine with it. And when they saw it worked they made Anniversary! And as for the storyline I liked it! It was a lot better than some of the other ones! So you liked the short NON-EXISTANT ones in TR5? Okay so your going on about storylines eh, so please explain the lack of story explaining how Lara survived the Temple Of Horus eh? It was left to a comic to explain how she survived!

Titanium your explanation is just full of holes! AoD was crap pure and simple (so was 4 and 5) Legend restored my faith in TR again

Rivendell
05-09-08, 08:37
:vlol:

Admit it Titanium! AoD needs to be put in the bin right now, and you should buy a few more copies of Legend because it's the best ever - you should be thanking Crystal Dynamics.

Now go. Go to church and renounce your faith in favour of your new god, See-Dee.

:vlol:

Seriously Chakotay, grow up. You're not going to do yourself any favours if you continue to attempt to ram your righteous opinion down other fans throats, when they've as much right to their own opinion as you do to yours. Telling people they're wrong isn't the right way to go.

Afonya
05-09-08, 08:40
I haven't played all Tomb Raiders through yet, but I rate anyway...

TR1 - 9½
TR2 - 8
TR3 - 10
TR4 - 9-
TR5 - 7+
TRL - 6
TRA - 9-

(I was surprised how good Anniversary was, except it's too easy compared to TR 1. But I love TRA)

Survival
05-09-08, 08:46
No Titanium CRYSTAL DYNAMICS RESTORED THE SERIES AFTER THE TERRIBLE CRAP THAT WAS 5 AND AoD!! The reason it was short was because they were trying a new game engine with it. And when they saw it worked they made Anniversary! And as for the storyline I liked it! It was a lot better than some of the other ones! So you liked the short NON-EXISTANT ones in TR5? Okay so your going on about storylines eh, so please explain the lack of story explaining how Lara survived the Temple Of Horus eh? It was left to a comic to explain how she survived!

Titanium your explanation is just full of holes! AoD was crap pure and simple (so was 4 and 5) Legend restored my faith in TR again

...

Thank you for reminding me how much and why I hate Legend. The disc just ended in the bin after being thrown like frisbee around my flat ;).

:vlol:

Admit it Titanium! AoD needs to be put in the bin right now, and you should buy a few more copies of Legend because it's the best ever - you should be thanking Crystal Dynamics.

Now go. Go to church and renounce your faith in favour of your new god, See-Dee.

:vlol:

Seriously Chakotay, grow up. You're not going to do yourself any favours if you continue to attempt to ram your righteous opinion down other fans throats, when they've as much right to their own opinion as you do to yours. Telling people they're wrong isn't the right way to go.

:tmb:

kryptonite23
05-09-08, 09:47
**~**

Tomb Raider 1 ~ 7/10
Tomb Raider 2 : Dagger of Xian ~ 10/10
Tomb Raider 3 : Adventures of Lara Croft ~ 9/10
Tomb Raider 4 : Last Revelation ~ 7/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles ~ 9/10
Tomb Raider : Angel of Darkness ~ 8/10
Tomb Raider Legend ~ 8/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary ~ 9/10

**~**

Gothlegend
05-09-08, 19:50
i'd give all of them about a 9/10 :)

Titanium
05-09-08, 20:00
so please explain the lack of story explaining how Lara survived the Temple Of Horus eh?

[/B]

Eidos forced them to make another Tomb Raider game before AOD, this went against Cores plans causing a stir in the development of AOD. Core simply did not have enough time, thats why all the story related issues between Last Revelation and AOD.

Secondly mate, its just a couple of games, I like one more then the other, no need to get so serious about it. :)

:vlol:

Admit it Titanium! AoD needs to be put in the bin right now, and you should buy a few more copies of Legend because it's the best ever - you should be thanking Crystal Dynamics.

Now go. Go to church and renounce your faith in favour of your new god, See-Dee.

:vlol:


I will never admit to such blasphemy! :vlol:

chakotay1
05-09-08, 22:01
Eidos forced them to make another Tomb Raider game before AOD, this went against Cores plans causing a stir in the development of AOD. Core simply did not have enough time, thats why all the story related issues between Last Revelation and AOD.

Secondly mate, its just a couple of games, I like one more then the other, no need to get so serious about it. :)



I will never admit to such blasphemy! :vlol:

Titanium If it was anything else I would understand but NOT that:cen::cen::cen: excuse for a TR game AoD! the game that finally killed the TR series for years until Eidos told Core to :cen: off and went to Crystal who revived the series. AoD is a JOKE a :cen: up mess of a game which doesn't deserve to be even called TR! I refused to pay even £3 for it! So you like bad cameras, controlls and bugs and stuff fine! I personally would rather have the GORGEOUS controlls, graphics and camera of Legend.

LEGEND THE BEST TR SINCE TR2! LEGEND THE GAME THAT REVIVED THE SERIES!

TRhalloween
05-09-08, 22:06
Titanium If it was anything else I would understand but NOT that:cen::cen::cen: excuse for a TR game AoD! the game that finally killed the TR series for years until Eidos told Core to :cen: off and went to Crystal who revived the series. AoD is a JOKE a :cen: up mess of a game which doesn't deserve to be even called TR! I refused to pay even £3 for it! So you like bad cameras, controlls and bugs and stuff fine! I personally would rather have the GORGEOUS controlls, graphics and camera of Legend.

LEGEND THE BEST TR SINCE TR2! LEGEND THE GAME THAT REVIVED THE SERIES!

OK I'm not a big fan of AoD, but people are allowed to have opinions. Nothing sucks, nothing rocks.Everything is according to opinion.

Mad Tony
05-09-08, 22:08
Titanium If it was anything else I would understand but NOT that:cen::cen::cen: excuse for a TR game AoD! the game that finally killed the TR series for years until Eidos told Core to :cen: off and went to Crystal who revived the series. AoD is a JOKE a :cen: up mess of a game which doesn't deserve to be even called TR! I refused to pay even £3 for it! So you like bad cameras, controlls and bugs and stuff fine! I personally would rather have the GORGEOUS controlls, graphics and camera of Legend.

LEGEND THE BEST TR SINCE TR2! LEGEND THE GAME THAT REVIVED THE SERIES!Calm down. Titanium is entitled to think what he wants.

Although I'm not too keen on AoD, I still regard it as more of a Tomb Raider game than Legend ever was. To me, Legend just killed the series completely. By killed I don't mean as in sales, I mean that I feel it's not a Tomb Raider game at all.

Titanium
05-09-08, 22:14
Titanium If it was anything else I would understand but NOT that:cen::cen::cen: excuse for a TR game AoD! the game that finally killed the TR series for years until Eidos told Core to :cen: off and went to Crystal who revived the series. AoD is a JOKE a :cen: up mess of a game which doesn't deserve to be even called TR! I refused to pay even £3 for it! So you like bad cameras, controlls and bugs and stuff fine! I personally would rather have the GORGEOUS controlls, graphics and camera of Legend.

LEGEND THE BEST TR SINCE TR2! LEGEND THE GAME THAT REVIVED THE SERIES!

Yes, I'm happy with my bad camera, dodgy controls and bugs thanks. Enjoy Legend! :)

Angelus
05-09-08, 22:20
Wait - people didn't like Legend?

I HATE YOU ALL AND WISH THAT EVERY GAME YOU OWN TURNS INTO LEGEND! :mad::mad::mad::mad::mad:

violentblossom
05-09-08, 22:22
I don't know why some people get in such an uproar when somebody says they don't like Anniversary or Legend and gives it a low score.

bleh, don't understand all the Legend disliking.

Rivendell
05-09-08, 22:24
To me, Legend just killed the series completely. By killed I don't mean as in sales, I mean that I feel it's not a Tomb Raider game at all.

And you know you're definitely not alone in thinking that. Heck, the legend section was a bombsite until TR:A was announced and took the focus off it.

Wait - people didn't like Legend?


Shockin' innint! :eek:

Angelus
05-09-08, 22:26
And you know you're definitely not alone in thinking that. Heck, the legend section was a bombsite until TR:A was announced and took the focus off it.



Shockin' innint! :eek:

It's not shocking, it's disgusting!

Zebra
05-09-08, 22:29
Tomb Raider: 8/10
Tomb Raider 2: Haven't played it.
Tomb Raider 3: Haven't played it.
Tomb Raider LR: Haven't played it.
Tomb Raider Chronicles: Haven't played it.
Tomb Raider AoD: 9.5/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 6/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 5/10

b0bb13
05-09-08, 22:38
And you know you're definitely not alone in thinking that. Heck, the legend section was a bombsite until TR:A was announced and took the focus off it.

Yeah,I joined right before it was announced,and I posted in the 'TR8 Lara' thread that I'd like her to be like in Legend,and all you evil people bashed my newbish post!I hate you and I wish you all get killed by Janice with her cigarettes!:mad:

Live Legend Aloan!And Haw ******* Daer Any1 Out Thear Maek Fun Of Legend?!Aftah All It's Bean Thru!It's A HUMAN!http://www.unity.i8i.co.uk/forum/images/smiley_cry.gif

:rolleyes::p

KC Mraz
05-09-08, 22:52
Yeah,I joined right before it was announced,and I posted in the 'TR8 Lara' thread that I'd like her to be like in Legend,and all you evil people bashed my newbish post!

Awww :hug:

Rivendell
05-09-08, 22:54
:D I wish there were more fans like yourself b0bb13 :tmb: Lots of fans need to lighten up the humor.

Cheers. :hug:

Larapink
05-09-08, 22:57
Okayyy, I thought this was about rating your fave TR games. :confused:

TRhalloween
05-09-08, 22:59
Okayyy, I thought this was about rating your fave TR games. :confused:

It used to be

Agent 47
05-09-08, 23:01
Calm down. Titanium is entitled to think what he wants.

Although I'm not too keen on AoD, I still regard it as more of a Tomb Raider game than Legend ever was. To me, Legend just killed the series completely. By killed I don't mean as in sales, I mean that I feel it's not a Tomb Raider game at all.

that's about right MT :D you never know TRU might recapture the classic feel

b0bb13
05-09-08, 23:28
Awww :hug:

It's so hard being a noob.:p
:hug:

:D I wish there were more fans like yourself b0bb13 :tmb: Lots of fans need to lighten up the humor.

Cheers. :hug:

Aww,thanks.:hug:
Buuuuut...you were one of teh people that flamed me!Beware because I can haz cheez.....I mean I can see teh future.:mis:
http://i132.photobucket.com/albums/q24/b0bb13/TRAOD_P42008-07-2922-29-36-10.jpg
If you guess why you have those eyes,then I shall be given a cookie.:D

Okayyy, I thought this was about rating your fave TR games. :confused:

:vlol:
I love all my Tomb Raider games,and they all get a big 10+ from me.:hug:
Happy now,lol?:p

TRhalloween
05-09-08, 23:31
"Kung fu prostitute" is fun to say.

Tomb Raider Anniversary mobile-7.8/10 (mobile standards)

fanoflaracroft
05-09-08, 23:53
Tomb raider 1 10/10
Tomb raider 2 10/10
Tomb raider 3 10/10
Tomb raider 4 10/10
Tomb raider 5 10/10
Tomb raider 6 10/10
Tomb raider 7 10/10
Tomb raider anniversary 10/10:)

TRhalloween
05-09-08, 23:55
Tomb raider 1 10/10
Tomb raider 2 10/10
Tomb raider 3 10/10
Tomb raider 4 10/10
Tomb raider 5 10/10
Tomb raider 6 10/10
Tomb raider 7 10/10
Tomb raider anniversary 10/10:)

That's pretty harsh! It's no mercy with you! :eek:

:vlol:

fanoflaracroft
05-09-08, 23:58
That's pretty harsh! It's no mercy with you! :eek:

:vlol:
Tomb raider forever!:hug:

Larapink
06-09-08, 01:03
Tomb raider 1 10/10
Tomb raider 2 10/10
Tomb raider 3 10/10
Tomb raider 4 10/10
Tomb raider 5 10/10
Tomb raider 6 10/10
Tomb raider 7 10/10
Tomb raider anniversary 10/10:)
Good, but AOD 10/10? :vlol:

I rated AOD 0/10, I lost interest in TR because of it. :vlol:

Legend bought me back as a fan of TR again. :D

fanoflaracroft
06-09-08, 01:11
Good, but AOD 10/10? :vlol:

I rated AOD 0/10, I lost interest in TR because of it. :vlol:

Legend bought me back as a fan of TR again. :D
It had some interesting things like gaining power by opening doors. I've never seen that before.

b0bb13
06-09-08, 01:22
^Those are the worst things in AOD,imo.:p:vlol:
It had Janice,so that's enough.:D

Good, but AOD 10/10? :vlol:

I rated AOD 0/10, I lost interest in TR because of it. :vlol:

Legend bought me back as a fan of TR again. :D

Must we start the war again?I will hire Janice again if it's necessary.;)

http://i132.photobucket.com/albums/q24/b0bb13/TRAOD_P42008-07-2923-53-41-90.jpg

It seems she has eliminated Riv,as he's gone offline.*evil laugh*:mis:

peeves
06-09-08, 01:25
TR1-8/10
TR2-8/10
TR3-8.5/10
TR4-8.3/10
TR5-9/10
TR6-10/10
TR7- -2/10 http://www.tombraiderforums.com/images/icons/icon13.gif
TRA-5/10
TR8-3/10

KC Mraz
06-09-08, 01:28
I will hire Janice again if it's necessary.;)

That could be understanded in a oh, so naughty way :mis: :vlol:

Larapink
06-09-08, 01:32
Opening doors, for power? :vlol:
I never had that, all I got was Lara falling down every 10 seconds in AOD, it was annyoing and a list of other bugs some times AOD Lara wouldn't move.:mad:

Must we start the war again?I will hire Janice again if it's necessary.;)

It seems she has eliminated Riv,as he's gone offline.*evil laugh*:mis:
It wasn't a war lol, it was revenge. :mis:


Really lol! :vlol:

b0bb13
06-09-08, 01:39
That could be understanded in a oh, so naughty way :mis: :vlol:

:vlol:

It wasn't a war lol, it was revenge. :mis:


Really lol! :vlol:

Just you wait missy!In maximum 2 ours,you'll be bathing in a pool of your own blood.:mis:

chakotay1
06-09-08, 16:24
have a lot of you escaped from the looney bins! I am completely :confused: and perplexed how a lot of you can give AoD the biggest :cen: up game ever created 9s and 10s and legend low scores! get a grip on reality folks LEGEND SAVED THE SERIES AND AoD KILLED IT!


Aod is a mess of a game Legend is a work of art! It made me fall in love with the game again!

people who love AoD :vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol:

peeves
06-09-08, 16:28
have a lot of you escaped from the looney bins! I am completely :confused: and perplexed how a lot of you can give AoD the biggest :cen: up game ever created 9s and 10s and legend low scores! get a grip on reality folks LEGEND SAVED THE SERIES AND AoD KILLED IT!


Aod is a mess of a game Legend is a work of art! It made me fall in love with the game again!

people who love AoD :vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol:

Well i rated legend -2/10 because i dislike it completely http://www.tombraiderforums.com/images/icons/icon13.gif No offense i dislike it the most and AOD is way much better than legend I rather have bugs glitches in aod than boring stuff in legend I mean legend is boring easy short and unpleasant. AOD on the other hand has a perfect plot outline a much longer game with better levels.

CroftScionGuard
06-09-08, 16:32
Well i rated legend 0/10 because that game has the most utter crap http://www.tombraiderforums.com/images/icons/icon13.gif No offense i dislike it the most and AOD is way much better than legend I rather have bugs glitches in aod than boring crap in legend I mean legend is boring easy short and unpleasant. AOD on the other hand has a perfect plot outline a much longer game with better levels.
I don't dislike totally TR:L, but I agree with you: TR:AOD's far better. A pity it wasn't finished

b0bb13
06-09-08, 16:33
have a lot of you escaped from the looney bins! I am completely :confused: and perplexed how a lot of you can give AoD the biggest :cen: up game ever created 9s and 10s and legend low scores! get a grip on reality folks LEGEND SAVED THE SERIES AND AoD KILLED IT!


Aod is a mess of a game Legend is a work of art! It made me fall in love with the game again!

people who love AoD :vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol:

Oh thank God that my mother gave me a good education,or I would certainly get banned.:)

Well i rated legend 0/10 because that game has the most utter crap http://www.tombraiderforums.com/images/icons/icon13.gif No offense i dislike it the most and AOD is way much better than legend I rather have bugs glitches in aod than boring crap in legend I mean legend is boring easy short and unpleasant. AOD on the other hand has a perfect plot outline a much longer game with better levels.

Why don't we just continue without paying attention to his/her posts?;)

Mad Tony
06-09-08, 16:57
have a lot of you escaped from the looney bins! I am completely :confused: and perplexed how a lot of you can give AoD the biggest :cen: up game ever created 9s and 10s and legend low scores! get a grip on reality folks LEGEND SAVED THE SERIES AND AoD KILLED IT!


Aod is a mess of a game Legend is a work of art! It made me fall in love with the game again!

people who love AoD :vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol:Se riously, what is wrong with you? You seem to relish the thought of anybody having a different opinion to you.

I hate Legend and I think AoD was ok. Let me guess, I'm completely wrong and insane? Excuse me while I go and check back into the mental hospital

peeves
06-09-08, 17:00
Seriously, what is wrong with you? You seem to relish the thought of anybody having a different opinion to you.

I hate Legend and I think AoD was ok. Let me guess, I'm completely wrong and insane?

Well said ;)
Here's my grade list from 1 to TRU
TR1 - B+
TR2 - B
TR3 - B+
TR4 - B+
TR5 - A
TR6 - A+
TRL - F-
TRA - F+
TRU - F

Agent 47
06-09-08, 17:01
Seriously, what is wrong with you? You seem to relish the thought of anybody having a different opinion to you.

I hate Legend and I think AoD was ok. Let me guess, I'm completely wrong and insane?

don't feed them MT ;)

chakotay1
06-09-08, 19:29
Good, but AOD 10/10? :vlol:

I rated AOD 0/10, I lost interest in TR because of it. :vlol:

Legend bought me back as a fan of TR again. :D

Larapink finally someone who has brains and has the same sense I do and saw AoD for what it was UTTER CRAP! And Legend for what it was SHEER BRILLIANCE! I had actually fallen out of love with TR after that apalling excuse of a game called Chronicles and like you it was Legend that brought me back!

I hope I am reading you right.

Olabelle
06-09-08, 19:45
Larapink finally someone who has brains and has the same sense I do and saw AoD for what it was UTTER CRAP! And Legend for what it was SHEER BRILLIANCE! I had actually fallen out of love with TR after that apalling excuse of a game called Chronicles and like you it was Legend that brought me back!

I hope I am reading you right.
That's right, keep beating them over the head with your opinion, eventually it'll sink in. Yeah.

Let them have their own opinions, because honestly, they probably couldn't care less how you view what they like.

I personally can't stand AOD, because it didn't feel like Tomb Raider to me. It wasn't crap, it just didn't have the same appeal the others did. Though, I did like the mutant fish bunches.

I like Legend, but not as a Tomb Raider game. It didn't reinvent anything in my opinion. If they'd have put a differant character in the role, you wouldn't have known it was TR. It was short, to the point, and over in a flash.

I only hope that Underworld actually turns out to be a decent game compared to the other two they've released. @.@

Titanium
06-09-08, 21:19
http://img122.imageshack.us/img122/4868/cantwealljustgetalongsi0.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

peeves
06-09-08, 21:24
http://img122.imageshack.us/img122/4868/cantwealljustgetalongsi0.jpg (http://imageshack.us)

Well said. Let's get all along full stop. :wve: I still think AOD was brilliant but people decide to go with their own opinions so be it. :pi:

Zebra
06-09-08, 21:30
Titanium If it was anything else I would understand but NOT that:cen::cen::cen: excuse for a TR game AoD! the game that finally killed the TR series for years until Eidos told Core to :cen: off and went to Crystal who revived the series. AoD is a JOKE a :cen: up mess of a game which doesn't deserve to be even called TR! I refused to pay even £3 for it! So you like bad cameras, controlls and bugs and stuff fine! I personally would rather have the GORGEOUS controlls, graphics and camera of Legend.

LEGEND THE BEST TR SINCE TR2! LEGEND THE GAME THAT REVIVED THE SERIES!

It is not all about controls and graphics. Of course Legend has good graphics. Of course Legend has responsive controls. But Legend has (in comparison to the classic Tomb Raiders and AoD) crappy gameplay. The gameplay is too easy and boring. And the atmosphere is also not exactly good (IMO).

Everybody has different opinions. You think Legend was good and AoD wasn't? Fine. But others perhaps think the exact opposite and you should respect that. Some people can simply see behind AoD's flaws. And if you do that you see the beauty that AoD was supposed to be.

thecentaur
06-09-08, 21:32
everything xcept aod coz i haven't played it yet, 10/10 IMO

...

Zebra
06-09-08, 21:35
everything xcept aod coz i haven't played it yet, 10/10 IMO

...

LoL!
You were just too lazy :p.

Larapink
06-09-08, 21:39
Larapink finally someone who has brains and has the same sense I do and saw AoD for what it was UTTER CRAP! And Legend for what it was SHEER BRILLIANCE! I had actually fallen out of love with TR after that apalling excuse of a game called Chronicles and like you it was Legend that brought me back!

I hope I am reading you right.
Yeah that is almost like me, but I actually enjoyed Chronicles alot. AOD was the game I tried, I didn't like it that is when I lost interest in TR.

Legend got me back as a fan, I really enjoyed Legend.:jmp:

Zebra
06-09-08, 21:43
Larapink finally someone who has brains and has the same sense I do and saw AoD for what it was UTTER CRAP! And Legend for what it was SHEER BRILLIANCE! I had actually fallen out of love with TR after that apalling excuse of a game called Chronicles and like you it was Legend that brought me back!

I hope I am reading you right.

This sounds like you haven't even played AoD. So are you just saying these bad things about a game you haven't even played?

Agent 47
06-09-08, 21:50
This sounds like you haven't even played AoD. So are you just saying these bad things about a game you haven't even played?

i'd say more like trying to provoke people, it's in the tone ;)

pEhouse
06-09-08, 22:45
TR - 9/10
TR II - 8/10
TR III - 10/10
TLR - 10/10
Chronicles - 8/10
AoD - haven't played all the way through because of bugs, so I won't rate
Legend - 5/10
TRA - 7/10 (without the awful AD it could have been a higher rate)

TRhalloween
06-09-08, 22:49
TR - 9/10
TR II - 8/10
TR III - 10/10
TLR - 10/10
Chronicles - 8/10
AoD - haven't played all the way through because of bugs, so I won't rate
Legend - 5/10
TRA - 7/10 (without the awful AD it could have been a higher rate)

Well doesn't that tell you something?

pEhouse
06-09-08, 23:11
Well, I think I would have liked it if I got to play, so it annoys the hell outta me that I can't find out, and this is why I'm kinda torn. I can't give it a bad rating because the parts I could play I liked, and I can't give it a good rating because it didn't let me progress.

But I might get it again for PS2 for cheap and hope that I get to play the full game this time.

Ward Dragon
06-09-08, 23:28
Well, I think I would have liked it if I got to play, so it annoys the hell outta me that I can't find out, and this is why I'm kinda torn. I can't give it a bad rating because the parts I could play I liked, and I can't give it a good rating because it didn't let me progress.

But I might get it again for PS2 for cheap and hope that I get to play the full game this time.

If you get the Platinum version or Greatest Hits (whichever it's called where you are) then the bugs should be fixed :) I already had the PC version and I just got the PS2 version for less than $5. I prefer the PC version, but the PS2 version didn't have any major gameplay bugs either so hopefully you should be fine if you get the re-release of the PS2 version :)

Eddie Haskell
07-09-08, 03:35
Tomb Raider---10/10
Tomb Raider II---9/10
Tomb Raider III---9/10
Tomb Raider IV---8.5/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles---7.5/10
Tomb Raider:Angel of Darkness---7/10
Tomb Raider:Legend---0.25/10
Tomb Raider:Anniversary---0.75/10

*laralover*
07-09-08, 04:12
Tomb Raider 1 - 10/10
Tomb Raider 2 - 9/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 8/10
Tomb Raider 4 - 9/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles - 8/10
Tomb Raider AOD - 9/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 5/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 6/10

:wve:

chakotay1
07-09-08, 07:44
I think I have an idea of why there are a lot of gamers out there who love the Core games and hate the CD games. My theory is this: I rmember something similar about 20 years ago when a programme called STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION premiered in 1987 in the US and 1990 in the UK. A lot trekkies (myself included) refused to watch it saying things like "thats not Star Trek". "How the hell can you have ST with out Kirk and Spock" "yes it is ST in name only and Star Trek is only Star trek with Kirk and Spock! and what not! But then a lot of us got curious about it and to see what all the fuss is about so we tuned in, got to know the characters and realised it was a brilliant show so was Deep Space 9, Voyager and Enterprise but there are still trekkies out there (myself is one of them) that despite it being 40years old and the special effects are total crap compared to the spin-offs there was just something magical about the original series and it will never be beaten by the spin-offs and I think that is the way a lot of you feel about the CD TRs! Good games or average games it is just not the same without the original Core team making it!

Am I making any sense!

Nandu
07-09-08, 08:09
Well let's see...

TR1: 9/10
TR2: 10/10
TR3: 8/10
TR4: 7/10
Chronicles: 6/10
AoD: 4/10
Legend: 4/10
Anniversary: 7/10

Elysia
07-09-08, 09:13
I think I have an idea of why there are a lot of gamers out there who love the Core games and hate the CD games. My theory is this: I rmember something similar about 20 years ago when a programme called STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION premiered in 1987 in the US and 1990 in the UK. A lot trekkies (myself included) refused to watch it saying things like "thats not Star Trek". "How the hell can you have ST with out Kirk and Spock" "yes it is ST in name only and Star Trek is only Star trek with Kirk and Spock! and what not! But then a lot of us got curious about it and to see what all the fuss is about so we tuned in, got to know the characters and realised it was a brilliant show so was Deep Space 9, Voyager and Enterprise but there are still trekkies out there (myself is one of them) that despite it being 40years old and the special effects are total crap compared to the spin-offs there was just something magical about the original series and it will never be beaten by the spin-offs and I think that is the way a lot of you feel about the CD TRs! Good games or average games it is just not the same without the original Core team making it!

.... and then... there are just those of us who don't particularly like Legend. We're allowed not to like it - it isn't as if there's some kind of magical contract out there that says 'but... but... but... You're a Tomb Raider fan! How can you not like Legend?!?! YOU MUST LOVE IT! Love it... LOVE IT!!!'. Some of us played it, found it to be easy, linear and lacking in atmosphere or challenge and decided 'nope - don't like this' - doesn't make us wrong, insane or CD haters (I, for example, love the LoK games, as do many alleged 'CD haters' here)... it just makes us have a differing opinion.

Anyway - oh topic.

TR1: 10/10. I love this game with a passion - the original and the best :D. Yes, it looks a bit shonky nowadays, and yes, it does have its faults (why can't Lara crawl?!) but back in the day, this really was the dog's balls. I seriously, seriously doubt anyone will be looking back at Legend 12 years on and lauding it as much as people still laud the first Tomb Raider...
TR2: 7.5/10. Good game... but too many human enemies ruin the atmosphere for me a bit. That and some of the level design decisions ('pull lever, go down shaft, travel approximately 15 miles only to end up in the same room that you were in half an hour previously to open a door that was next to the original lever you pulled in the first place...) are, quite frankly, appalling; I am all for challenging gameplay and having levels as puzzles, but some areas of TR2 really did push even my near boundless capability to suspend my disbelief. Yes, Offshore Rig level, I am talking about YOU!)
TR3: 10/10. To me, this really is level design at its pinnacle... Aldwych is just a masterpiece. :tmb: I love TR3 because it is hard and really makes you work rather than in spite of this. In Ely world, ALL Tomb Raiders would be this challenging! :D
TR:TLR: 9/10. I love TLR, especially the whole 'Cleopatra' sections, but I was just ever so slightly disappointed by the least few levels... the whole Cairo thang didn't do as much for me. Still, this really is one of the most innovative of the classic games, and therefore still scores bit points with me!
TR Chronicles: 6.5/10. Tired and obviously a cash-in, I still enjoy the VCI levels. Yes... I know I am probably the only person in existence to say this, but I thought the VCI levels had some interesting gameplay elements thrown into the mix.
AoD: 6/10 AoD is a hard one... when it is good, it is very, very good, but when it is bad, it's just downright horrible. It has the TR atmosphere in many of the places (although I still maintain a lot of the content - especially the Dig Site stuff - was ripped from The Lost Artefact! Seriously - play Lost Artefact's 2nd level and then play AoD. They're very similar!), but the controls were too sloppy for words (I never really ran against any bugs as such). This was also the beginning of the 'huge, complex level design' downfall... areas were still pretty big, but things were definitely simpler than in previous installments.
Legend: 4/10 ... and I am being generous here. Linear and easy (to an almost insulting degree), this game was so obviously squarely aimed at the casual gamer market, it's almost painful. Gone are any elements of exploration, challenge or atmosphere, only to be replaced with pole swinging, monkey-hopping and chattering imbeciles. Simply mediocre on all and every level, Legend did what it was supposed to do - ensnare a new audience by making it accessible to those whom even a concussed kitten could outsmart, but for those of us used to a much more cerebral, challenging TR experience, it left us feeling cheated and vaguely insulted.
TRA: 6.5/10. The Ultimate in Schizophrenic Tomb Raider Games... like AoD, when it is good, it is very, very good (excellent, maybe... SFF was just sublime!), but when it is bad, it is cut down, simplified and frustrating. Being stuck because you don't know where to go or what to do next = fun and rewarding when you work it out. Being stuck because the stupid wall run won't work = just plain irritating. More of a manual dexterity test than a brain-workout, TRA scores big points with me over a few levels - Caves, SFF (oh, how I love that level!), parts of Egypt. However, as soon as the controls and camera decide to start acting like a bunch of lobotomised monkeys programmed them (with Lara stubbornly refusing to grab ledges all of a sudden, the camera all of a sudden veering off into space meaning Lara jumps off at weird angles and, my personal bugbear, the grapple-wall run- backflip move), then big points start getting taken away. Combine that with every level looking huge but then severely shrinking down to size when you realise that most of it is painted backdrop... TRA is a step in the right direction, but is still lacking in true exploration and really complex, innovative level design. Hopefully, TRU will raise the bar again ;).

MiCkiZ88
07-09-08, 09:54
Tomb Raider: 9/10 Original is always the best, but it's not my favorite. Maybe because I started with TRIII area51 demo and then TRII and got used to high tech locations, human enemies and sci-fi meets ancient history.

Tomb Raider II: 10/10 This game is the first full TR I ever played. I loved everything about it. The locations, the amazing atmosphere (extremely creepy at some points) and even the human enemies. Venice has to be the favorite location. So many jump out moments and I just love Venice's architechture.

Tomb Raider III: 8/10 Good game, and I absolutely loved Nevada, India and Antartica. But I wasn't so much in to the story.

Tomb Raider IV: 10/10 This and TRII are my favorite TR games. I'm mad about Egypt cause of this game, and I fell in love with the music. Probs has the best score imo. This game was extremely creepy at certain points. Dark and mysterious. Not to mention the story is one of the best ones in TR.

Tomb Raider C: 5/10 Blegh.. A cheap cash in. Only loved the VCI and Rome levels. Ely, you aint the only one.

Tomb Raider AoD: 9/10. I actually had zero problems with controls and I didn't even notice any bugs! I loved the story and the cinematic feel. Hated combat, but loved stealth.

Tomb Raider Legend: 6/10 Not a good TR game, but it was a nice casual game. As a TR game it would be 3/10. Lara's bio changed, she was all over the place, and the two monkeys got annoying after the first playthrough.

Tomb Raider Anniversary: 7/10. Much better than Legend, but it still missed something. Maybe it was better cause there was no real mention of her mother? eh.. I don't know.

Drone
07-09-08, 09:54
TR1: 10/10
I love this game. My first step in tomb raiding :)

TR2: 9/10
This game is cool too but too action.

TR3: 9/10
Love this game. But not enough tombs there :)

TR4: 10/10
Super game. One of my favourite. Puzzles and action ... everythig is just perfect


Chronicles: 9/10
Kick-ass game. I did't like it b4 but after I finished it 3 times I love it now :)

AoD: 11/10
No comments :) I just can't live without AoD :tmb:

chakotay1
07-09-08, 10:21
er to every :cln: who hates Legend and likes Aod! Well I have just checked the sales figures for the games on Wiki and guess what TOMB RAIDER LEGEND HAS OUT SOLD ALL THE OTHER TOMB RAIDERS EXCEPT TR1!

here are the chart figure for each TR game and there posistion in the US and UK charts:

TR 1 - US - No1 UK - No1

TR 2 - US - No3

TR 3 - US - No4

TR 4 - US - No1 UK - No1

TR 5 - US - No16

TR 6 - US - No27 UK - No - 15:vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol:

TR 7 - US - No2 UK - No1:ton::D

So stick that somewhere and admit that AoD is total crap and that EVERY sane TR player was sick and tired of Cores crap So there you are LEGEND RULES and all you Aod :cln: are cuckoo and in the minorty for liking it!

Geck-o-Lizard
07-09-08, 10:33
TR1: N/A - uncompleted

TR2: N/A - uncompleted

TR3: 8/10 - fantastic locations and stunning scenery, specially for its time. The London levels were my favourites; I still think of them every time I go outside at night and hear the wind whistling and distant trains rattling along. I've spent years playing this game.

TR4: 6/10 - interesting puzzles and locations, but way too long. Got lost two thirds of the way through and never bothered finishing it.

TR5: 5/10 - weak and uninspired. The only levels I remember with any detail are the Dark Isle ones, which genuinely scared me, lol. They're why it gets 5 points instead of 3.

AoD: 9/10 - absolutely loved it. The story and environments pulled me in more than any other game I've ever played. I only experienced one bug and it was a minor texturing error, and I've played it through on both PS2 and PC. The controls didn't bother me.

TRL: 3/10 - what a disaster. Boring, repetititititive, linear, entirely at odds with the previous games in both style and substance. Little more than a showcase of CD's art department.

TRA: 5/10 - better than Legend, but I got bored when I was getting close to the end and never bothered to finish it. Bizarrely, the puzzles all felt like copies of each other: pressure pad, timer, lever. The original TRs managed to do this without feeling like every puzzle was the first one recoloured a dozen different ways.



I even refused to buy AoD for £3 from Blockbusters

You've never actually played it? What a valuable critic you are.

Elysia
07-09-08, 10:35
... and your point is? Scary Movie grossed $42,346,669 (USD) in the opening weekend in the box-office and went on to gross a total of $157,019,771 at the domestic box-office and a world-wide total of $278,019,771, whilst Pan's Labyrinth made $5.4 million in the first three weeks at the United States box office and as of March 1, 2007, it has grossed over $37 million in North America, and grossed $80 million worldwide. So Scary Movie has made a lot more money than Pan's Labyrinth... still doesn't stop Pan's Labyrinth being the better movie (from an objective AND subjective point of view), though.

Not only that, but this comment has no place here in this discussion at all. So what if Legend outsold AoD? It was about as challenging as finding a slapper in a nightclub... of course more people bought it - it was more accessible. It was designed to be like that. This thread, however, is about how people personally feel about the games, not how well they sold, so stay on topic.

On a more serious note - talk to people like that, and your opinion will largely be disregarded, no matter what it is. When people start stomping around, demanding that people see things their way and that if they don't, there is something wrong with them, I invariably put that person in the 'no real point to make - ignore' box in my head. Some people like AoD. Does it hurt you that they do? Did AoD come along and kick your dog? Did an AoD fan come and set fire to your house? No? Then pack it in with the personal bashing. Having opinions is fine - it's what we're all about - but being, to put it bluntly, a vaguely annoying bigot over it all is not and will not be tolerated for much longer.

As for everyone else - troll food is not available for sale here ;). This is a pre-emptive 'let's all stay on topic', m'kay?

Spikey
07-09-08, 13:49
TR1
9/10: A great game, though there were a few moments of the game which dragged it down a bit from perfection (notably The Cistern...which I've never liked despite the fanbase it has :p ).

TR2
9.5/10: Pretty much perfect in my opinion, bar The Deck which I despise (and also happens to be another popular level which I can never warm to :rolleyes: ).

TR3
8.5/10: Brilliant environments and variety, but the gameplay wasn't always to my taste, and anything involving vehicles+water (such as the hard to control kayak, and annoying multi-tunneled UPU section) really got on my nerves after a while. The PC version is also my superior in my eyes, since it doesn't have the saving system that the PS1 had. *shudder*

TR4
8.5/10: Pretty much classic TR fun, until City of the Dead, at which point everything goes a bit downhill. Almost everything before then is brilliant though. :)

TRC
8.5/10: A bit short and easy compared to the previous TR games, but still fun nonetheless and packed with a few clever gameplay moments (most of which are in VCI which I thought was a great levelset...you're not alone Elysia! :D ). Rome and Black Isle are also pretty enjoyable, and while I'm not so keen on the later levels of the Russia episode, it was still quite good.

AOD
8.5/10: Great storyline, great audio and mostly great gameplay. I never had any major problems with the controls, and I was lucky enough to get a mostly bug-free copy which didn't hinder any enjoyment. The only thing I could have asked for is a little less plodding-around gameplay near the beginning of the game, and a few more non-urban levels. I also really liked the "upgrades" system, which gave me incentive to re-explore past levels for more secrets.

TRL
7/10: Fun, but insanely short and easy. At least it had replay value for me in terms of unlockables.

TRA
8/10: Shorter and easier than TR1, but still mostly fun. It's a shame that many levels got cut down and lost a lot of gameplay though, but what was there was good enough...though on the upside, at least they deleted most of The Cistern. :vlol:


All scores are based on my overall enjoyment and opinion of the game, and not based on how well it fares as a Tomb Raider game itself. :) (hence why I still gave some of the later games a good score, even though sections of them are as far removed from "tomb raiding" as you can possibly get)

Jordan_Boi
07-09-08, 15:08
TR1 - Well, I never have been a massive fan of this. Back in the day I could never get round to finishing it. Until I get it on the PC, I can't really judge it much. But going by what I've played on the PS, it's been fun. :) 6/10.

TR2 - I used to hate this one, mostly because of how Lara sounded, and because I played TR3 I got annoyed at the lack of moves. But I got it for the PC, I absolutely loved it. Massive environments, lots of shooting, and it's very challenging, it's one of my favourite TR games. 9/10.

TR3 - My all time favourite. I think it was my first TR game. I played this for hours on end with my cousin. I adore the areas and how beautiful they look, even for how old it is. And the music. Oh my god, the TR3 theme is bloody fantastic, CD should learn a thing or to. Plus, this one has probably scared me the most too. :p 10/10.

TR4 - Ugh. Awful. First, the whole game is set in Egypt, my least favourite area in a TR game. Secondly, it's way too dark and complicated for me. I'm not a patient person, and it irritates me. And lastly, Lara. Her voice sounds like a little girl's when she jumps. Where'd our womanly Lara go from TR2/TR3? :( I haven't really given this a chance yet. Maybe I will someday, but it just doesn't work for me. 3/10.

TRC - I will admit... A few years back I downloaded this illegally. It was quite a perfect copy, except the FMVs had no sound to them. I liked the idea of visiting Lara's past, the new moves, different outfits. I loved the Submarine levels most of all, they were lush. About a year or two ago I bought TRC for the first time. I finished it and enjoyed it again. 8/10.

TR6 - I have mixed feelings about AOD. It takes a while to get into it for me. The bugs put me off. But when I first got into it and finished it, I loved every minute. The storyline and music are some of the best I've seen in a TR game. I love climbing almost anything, just like in the old games. Only thing I didn't like was the lack of dual pistols. It was disappointing and I was forced to use hand to hand combat a lot. It's Lara's conversations that make me **** myself laughing every time. "You unsavoury little runt." :D You're thinking, who the hell says that? And that's why it's so funny. 7/10.

TRL - Mmm. When I first played this on the Xbox, I actually quite enjoyed it. Beautiful environments, new moves, new Lara, everything. That was before I realised what a disappointment this turned out to be. After looking on the forums and seeing what was cut, it annoyed me. The length was what did it as well. Way too short, way too many human enemies, and they were TOO EASY TO KILL! Bleh. 5/10.

TRA - I really don't think Anniversary was that bad. I loved how clean and smooth it was. The levels, even on my crappy PC looked wonderful. A lot of elements were improved from Legend, showing you how CD are getting a little better in terms of designing. But it wasn't particularly perfect either. Boss rooms were restricting, Adrenaline dodge was the only way to defeat them. I HATE adrenaline dodging. 7/10.

TRhalloween
07-09-08, 15:55
I think I'm the only one here who actually likes Legend.

er to every :cln: who hates Legend and likes Aod! Well I have just checked the sales figures for the games on Wiki and guess what TOMB RAIDER LEGEND HAS OUT SOLD ALL THE OTHER TOMB RAIDERS EXCEPT TR1!

here are the chart figure for each TR game and there posistion in the US and UK charts:

TR 1 - US - No1 UK - No1

TR 2 - US - No3

TR 3 - US - No4

TR 4 - US - No1 UK - No1

TR 5 - US - No16

TR 6 - US - No27 UK - No - 15:vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol::vlol:

TR 7 - US - No2 UK - No1:ton::D

So stick that somewhere and admit that AoD is total crap and that EVERY sane TR player was sick and tired of Cores crap So there you are LEGEND RULES and all you Aod :cln: are cuckoo and in the minorty for liking it!

Please drop it! People are allowed to have opinions! We don't all have to have your brilliant opinion.

violentblossom
07-09-08, 16:09
actually, i like Legend, too. :wve:

Naz2000
07-09-08, 16:26
^I love Legend, I'm playing it right now:) Sure it isn't as fun as it was years ago but I still enjoy playing it.

Jordan_Boi
07-09-08, 18:27
Ugh. Will someone ban Chakotay? I'm sick to the back teeth of him.

Yuna´s Wish
07-09-08, 18:34
Maybe chakotay can participate in non-tombraiderish debates? :)

Interesting scores I´ve seen in this thread, keep posting people

Elysia
07-09-08, 18:43
A nice reminder that this is a 'rate TR' thread, not a 'feed the troll with impunity' thread... ;) Stay on topic as much as possible, please! :)

Ward Dragon
07-09-08, 22:01
Combine that with every level looking huge but then severely shrinking down to size when you realise that most of it is painted backdrop... TRA is a step in the right direction, but is still lacking in true exploration and really complex, innovative level design. Hopefully, TRU will raise the bar again ;).

One of the Leipzig videos seemed to have an Eidos representative talking to the player and he said that everything you can see in Underworld can be explored. He specifically pointed out a temple, saying it looked like a painted backdrop but the player would be able to actually get there later on in the level :D

ivannnnn
07-09-08, 22:22
For the old games, I voted 9/10
For the new one. 8/10

Quasimodo
08-09-08, 01:25
TR2 - 9/10
TR4 - 8/10
TRC - 6/10
TRAOD - 7/10 (I loved the story and dark tone)
TRL - 4/10 (a new game from any new developer would have "revived" the series at that point. CD is not a golden god amongst developers just because they got the job)
TRA - 3.8/10 (something about it just bores me to tears when I try to replay it)Turns out that something was Palace Midas. So now I'd give it a 7.5/10 :)

petujaymz
08-09-08, 16:12
Tomb Raider: I've never played it.

Tomb Raider 2: My memories of TR2 are too vague.

Tomb Raider 3: 7.25/10

Tomb Raider LR: 8.5/10

Tomb Raider Chronicles: 7.25/10

Tomb Raider AoD: 7.5/10

Tomb Raider Legend: 5/10

Tomb Raider Anniversary: 8.25/10

Were it not for TRL my scores would be a little different.

TRL has become the measure of how crap a TR game can be.

:wve:

ajrich17901
08-09-08, 16:35
Tomb Raider: 9/10
Tomb Raider 2: 10/10
Tomb Raider 3: 6/10
Tomb Raider LR: 5/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 4/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 8/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 7/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 7/10

tizerist
08-09-08, 19:57
Tomb Raider...........................................9/10
Tomb Raider II.........................................5/10
Tomb Raider III.......................................8/10
Tomb Raider The Last Revelation........... 10/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles ............................6.5/10

Tombreaper
08-09-08, 20:13
Tomb Raider...........................................9/10
Tomb Raider II.........................................5/10
Tomb Raider III.......................................8/10
Tomb Raider The Last Revelation........... 10/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles ............................6.5/10


TR II 5 out of 10? :confused:

b0bb13
08-09-08, 20:13
^Lol,I guess it's his opinion.:)
Just like TLR is pink.:vlol::p
j/k

I think I'm the only one here who actually likes Legend.

Actually,Legend is my favourite game ever!:D
I know that it's not the best game ever,but it's my favourite.:)

I love all TR games,but I sometimes I kinda get mad when I see everyone bash Legend.Sometimes I stay silent,but sometimes I defend it,but I don't trash and beat the living hell out of the game I 'bash',lol.:p

TRhalloween
08-09-08, 20:18
^Lol,I guess it's his opinion.:)
Just like TLR is pink.:vlol::p
j/k



Actually,Legend is my favourite game ever!:D
I know that it's not the best game ever,but it's my favourite.:)

I love all TR games,but I sometimes I kinda get mad when I see everyone bash Legend.Sometimes I stay silent,but sometimes I defend it,but I don't trash and beat the living hell out of the game I 'bash',lol.:p

It was my favourite game. But I finally gave TR1 a shot and I think it might come second. Or at least a co-holder.

DragonSlayer
08-09-08, 20:44
TR1 10/10
TR2 9/10
TR3 10/10
TLR 9/10 loses a point because Lara’s home is missing from the game
Chronicles 9/10 loses a point because Lara’s home is missing from the game
AOD 20/10
Legend 1/10 the game was too easy and too short and the story was boring traded it for GTA4 and lara’s mansion was awful the bike levels were unnecessary so too were the button prompts.
Anniversary 1/10 the t-rex boss fight was a let down traded it for GTA4 anniversary’s mansion is worse than legend’s mansion all that work just to get a piece of music.
The preowned shelf at game is too good a place for legend and anniversary in the trash is a more appropriate place
Tomb Raider The Prophecy 8/10

Tomb raider 1-6 and thet prophecy forever:hug:

Legend is a game for emo’s come to think of it when I bought legend there was an emo ahead of me in the queue buying it
Anniversary is a game for fans of badly done remakes

:jmp: Exactly couldnt agree with you more on that 1. Any one who has even given it 1 out of 10 is mad:hea:

Then i shall be the first legend 1/10 same for anniversary

Can the movies be included in this?
Tomb Raider 1 good but not great 5/10
Tomb Raider 2 awful 2/10

tizerist
09-09-08, 00:52
TR II 5 out of 10? :confused:
well let me just emphasise that glidos has saved TR1 from being the ugliest game in the series. TR2 also is far too metallic for my liking.

Here's a quick transcript of what was discussed during TR2 development.

Vijay: "Boss, after doing a quick runthrough of the beta version, theres a couple of things that need pointing out"
Boss: "Go on then. I ain't got all day though"
Vijay: "Right. Regarding the dinosaurs..."
Boss: "Yeah?"
Vijay: "We can't seriously put in a dinosaur that early in the game! At least in TR1 we built up the tension a bit first, you know, a bit of exploring beforehand...."
Boss: "Listen V, it was popular in TR1. It stays in the game! End of!"
Vijay: "But its right at the start! Everyones gonna know it was just a copy and paste from TR1! It doesn't fit!"
Boss: "It stays in! And just for your cheek, add another one! In the same level! We need this out by november Vijay! This is not a full-on sequel, there will be similar elements. Its to be expected."
Vijay: "Two in the same level? Thats just ridiculous! People are going to laugh at us, they will be able to tell that we have just..."
Boss: (Practising his golf swing) "Enough! Was there anything else Vijay?"
Vijay: "Er, yeah. The snow levels. They look awfully angular. It doesn't look like an organic environment at all!"
Boss: (Evil glare) "I'm warning you Vijay. We don't have a big budget for this. Just work around it. Look, you can just throw in a couple of installation or warehouse levels. They are angular by nature. Just do modern levels to make the squareness look a bit better."
Vijay: "Modern levels? Like metallic, boxy modern day levels? That's not very Tomb Raiderish!"
Boss: "Quit moaning about it. We need to just get this on the shelves. Didn't you mention something about an offshore rig type level? Something like that, for crying out loud.
Any extra cash for this project comes out of your wages, you hear? You still want to change that?"
Vijay: "OK, we'll skip that part. Aha! The audio! We have re-used quite a few of the ambient tracks from TR1. Can we get some fresh ones? Especially the heartbeat one. It doesn't fit as well as it does in TR1"
Boss: "We will keep the TR1 ambience from TR1. There was nothing wrong with it"
Vijay: "Yeah I know, but this is a different game! Even Street Fighter doesn't reuse its music in a sequel! Come on, seriously..."
Boss: "OK I'll think about it. Anything else?"
Vijay: "The floating islands has a black background with no textures. I can quickly make a wraparound to use in that level if you like"
Boss: "No, I don't like. The floating islands level is supposed to be a black background"
Vijay: "Supposed to be? Boss, it doesn't look that good..."
Boss: "Well the mythology states that it looks like that, so it will just stay like that, okay?"
Vijay: "LOL! Have you actually seen what it looks like though? It need at least a little bit of decoration. Just black looks too empty!"
Boss: "NO!"
Vijay: "Well what about the game length then? Its a little short at the mo."
Boss: "Add more mercanaries then. And more guns"
Vijay: "This is supposed to be an exploration game! We're going way off track here! Thats not the way to bump up game length!"
Boss: "I have targets to hit Vijay, and my patience is wearing thin with you son. You will add as many mercenaries as is necessary to get the game length up to the same as TR1, whether you like it or not. Just stick loads of 'em in! Your little attempts at 'quality control' are getting in the way of our project matey, and I suggest you start dropping those mercs in every corner you can find to get this thing underway. I know its a bit of a cop-out. You know that, I know that. But just do it, for my sake, eh? I've got the managing director putting pressure on me to deliver. What do you think he would say if I told him that its not correct to recycle TR1's music in TR2? He doesn't wanna hear that! And neither do I! So if you don't mind, please get back to work now. Close the door behind you please."
Vijay meekly exits the room, making sure not to close the door too loudly.

As I said before: TR2 - 5/10

Tombreaper
09-09-08, 01:32
well let me just emphasise that glidos has saved TR1 from being the ugliest game in the series. TR2 also is far too metallic for my liking.

Here's a quick transcript of what was discussed during TR2 development.

Vijay: "Boss, after doing a quick runthrough of the beta version, theres a couple of things that need pointing out"
Boss: "Go on then. I ain't got all day though"
Vijay: "Right. Regarding the dinosaurs..."
Boss: "Yeah?"
Vijay: "We can't seriously put in a dinosaur that early in the game! At least in TR1 we built up the tension a bit first, you know, a bit of exploring beforehand...."
Boss: "Listen V, it was popular in TR1. It stays in the game! End of!"
Vijay: "But its right at the start! Everyones gonna know it was just a copy and paste from TR1! It doesn't fit!"
Boss: "It stays in! And just for your cheek, add another one! In the same level! We need this out by november Vijay! This is not a full-on sequel, there will be similar elements. Its to be expected."
Vijay: "Two in the same level? Thats just ridiculous! People are going to laugh at us, they will be able to tell that we have just..."
Boss: (Practising his golf swing) "Enough! Was there anything else Vijay?"
Vijay: "Er, yeah. The snow levels. They look awfully angular. It doesn't look like an outside environment at all!"
Boss: (Evil glare) "I'm warning you Vijay. We don't have a big budget for this. Just work around it. Look, you can just throw in a couple of installation or warehouse levels. They are angular by nature. Just do modern levels to make the squareness look a bit better."
Vijay: "Modern levels? Like metallic, boxy modern day levels? That not very Tomb Raiderish!"
Boss: "Quit moaning about it. We need to just get this on the shelves. Didn't you mention something about an offshore rig type level? Something like that, for crying out loud.
Any extra cash for this project comes out of your wages, you hear? You still want to change that?"
Vijay: "OK, we'll skip that part. Aha! The audio! We have re-used quite a few of the ambient tracks from TR1. Can we get some fresh ones? Especially the heartbeat one. It doesn't fit as well as it does in TR1"
Boss: "We will keep the TR1 ambience from TR1. There was nothing wrong with it"
Vijay: "Yeah I know, but this is a different game! Even Street Fighter doesn't reuse its music in a sequel! Come on, seriously..."
Boss: "OK I'll think about it. Anything else?"
Vijay: "The floating islands has a black background with no textures. I can quickly make a wraparound to use in that level if you like"
Boss: "No, I don't like. The floating islands level is supposed to be a black background"
Vijay: "Supposed to be? Boss, it doesn't look that good..."
Boss: "Well the mythology states that it looks like that, so it will just stay like that, okay?"
Vijay: "LOL! Have you actually seen what it looks like though? It need at least a litlle bit of decoration. Just black looks too empty!"
Boss: "NO!"
Vijay: "Well what about the game length then? Its a little short at thre mo."
Boss: "Add more mercanaries then. And more guns"
Vijay: "This is supposed to be an exploration game! We're going way off track here! Thats not the way to bump up game length!"
Boss: "I have targets to hit Vijay, and my patience is wearing thin with you son. You will add as many mercenaries as is necessary to get the game length up to the same as TR1, whether you like it or not. Just stick loads of 'em in! Your little attempts at 'quality control' are getting in the way of our project matey, and I suggest you start dropping those mercs in every corner you can find to get this thing underway. I know its a bit of a cop-out. You know that, I know that. But just do it, for my sake, eh? I've got the managing director putting pressure on me to deliver. What do you think he would say if I told him that its not correct to recycle TR1's music in TR2? He doesn't wanna hear that! And neither do I! So if you don't mind, please get back to work now. Close the door behind you please."
Vijay meekly exits the room, making sure not to close the door too loudly.

As I said before: TR2 - 5/10


OK! :) but IMO it's personal, because I really didn't care about the T-rex thrown in that early in the game, actually it scared the sh*t out of me because I didn't expect a T-rex.
About the snow levels, they were well done for a 1997 game, and of course it appears angular as Lara needs the angular shapes to jump, hang etc, it's still a platform game at heart.
The Floating Islands level was very original done.
Indeed, there's nothing wrong with the game's audio, I agree here with Boss.
I never felt TR II has serious flaws, for me the game works perfect.
But, like I said, it's personal, some people like TR II, some people don't, but 5 out of 10 is a little on the short, the game deserves a higher rating.

Survival
09-09-08, 07:47
I agree with tizerist 100% ... :). And if there´s one thing that annoyed the hell out of me in TR2 it was the ridiculous and pointless fighting :).

lee32uk
09-09-08, 20:34
Tomb Raider: 10/10
Tomb Raider 2: 9/10
Tomb Raider 3: 7.5/10
Tomb Raider LR: 8.5/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 6/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 1/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 7/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 7/10

AmericanAssassin
09-09-08, 20:45
As I said before: TR2 - 5/10

:yik: TR2 is a masterpiece. That's the lowest rating I've ever seen it get. Wow. :(

peeves
09-09-08, 21:09
:yik: TR2 is a masterpiece. That's the lowest rating I've ever seen it get. Wow. :(

Ditto I think that all 6 classic TR's deserve to be at least an 8 but legend i still don't get why people rated legend higher than AOD :confused: I mean Bloody hell legend was too short and repititive and it got annoying after you played it for the millionth time so that's why i stopped legend for good and never even bother playing it again. Besides when i played legend 2 and a half years ago i didn't keep playing it til TRA came out in fact i didn't even play it for 3 months not even. i just played the 6 originals instead til TRA came out then i played TRA got bored of that too and played the 6 originals once again. TR's 1-6 are supposed to be games you'll like forever that you never get sick of.

TRhalloween
09-09-08, 22:20
Ditto I think that all 6 classic TR's deserve to be at least an 8 but legend i still don't get why people rated legend higher than AOD :confused: I mean Bloody hell legend was too short and repititive and it got annoying after you played it for the millionth time so that's why i stopped legend for good and never even bother playing it again. Besides when i played legend 2 and a half years ago i didn't keep playing it til TRA came out in fact i didn't even play it for 3 months not even. i just played the 6 originals instead til TRA came out then i played TRA got bored of that too and played the 6 originals once again. TR's 1-6 are supposed to be games you'll like forever that you never get sick of.

Be aware that this is my opinion and I'm not trying to convert anyone:

The Angel of Darkness

-Stealth is unnecessary
-Controls are atrocious
-Life-costing glitches
-Second playable character was unneeded
-More of an RPG. Not enough platform jumping.
-Lara's pistols are not in the game
-Terrible environments. Instead of exploring mysterious tombs, I'm stuck in sewers and boring streets.
-Lara has taken a down-grade. If a door is locked, kick it down! Lara needs to bust down a door with a crowbar to gain strength? Again an RPG element that doesn't belong in an adventure game.
-The story. Interesting, but doesn't fit in a Tomb Raider game. Lara accused of murder? Lara killing someone isn't a big deal. She has people in the past and gotten away.
-Poorly written dialogue . The story didn't work with a 1-dimensional character.

crux2
09-09-08, 22:49
Tomb Raider: 9/10
Tomb Raider 2: 9/10 - personal favourite.
Tomb Raider 3: 7/10
Tomb Raider LR: 9/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 8/10

Tomb Raider AoD: 4/10 (would have scored 7+ but I can't in all fairness give points for the 'might-have-been' effect.)

Tomb Raider Legend: 9/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 9/10

Tombreaper
09-09-08, 23:08
:off:

I still consider Legend as fast food.
But okay, the MTV generation likes it fast and easy.

TRhalloween
09-09-08, 23:12
:off:

I still consider Legend as fast food.
But okay, the MTV generation likes it fast and easy.

Why don't you understand!
That's a con not a pro!People don't like Legend because it's fast and easy, they tend to like it because of the gameplay and levels.

That's like saying people like the classic games because of the glitches.

Tombreaper
09-09-08, 23:22
they tend to like it because of the gameplay and levels.



Exactly, just like a BigMac :off:

peeves
09-09-08, 23:39
Exactly, just like a BigMac :off:

Well Remember the video of AOD vs. Legend I'll get it on youtube
click here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZVMJzhDhjZI)

b0bb13
09-09-08, 23:51
:yik: TR2 is a masterpiece. That's the lowest rating I've ever seen it get. Wow. :(

Oh noes!When someone rates your petty classics bad it's simply blasphemy,but for example if I would had said that at a legend 1/10 post,all of you would had buried me.Seriously,let people have they're opinions.;)

Ditto I think that all 6 classic TR's deserve to be at least an 8 but legend i still don't get why people rated legend higher than AOD :confused: I mean Bloody hell legend was too short and repititive and it got annoying after you played it for the millionth time so that's why i stopped legend for good and never even bother playing it again. Besides when i played legend 2 and a half years ago i didn't keep playing it til TRA came out in fact i didn't even play it for 3 months not even. i just played the 6 originals instead til TRA came out then i played TRA got bored of that too and played the 6 originals once again. TR's 1-6 are supposed to be games you'll like forever that you never get sick of.

Great,it's your opinion,now stop being chakotay2,please.:)

Be aware that this is my opinion and I'm not trying to convert anyone:

The Angel of Darkness

-Stealth is unnecessary
-Controls are atrocious
-Life-costing glitches
-Second playable character was unneeded
-More of an RPG. Not enough platform jumping.
-Lara's pistols are not in the game
-Terrible environments. Instead of exploring mysterious tombs, I'm stuck in sewers and boring streets.
-Lara has taken a down-grade. If a door is locked, kick it down! Lara needs to bust down a door with a crowbar to gain strength? Again an RPG element that doesn't belong in an adventure game.
-The story. Interesting, but doesn't fit in a Tomb Raider game. Lara accused of murder? Lara killing someone isn't a big deal. She has people in the past and gotten away.
-Poorly written dialogue . The story didn't work with a 1-dimensional character.

But it's teh best game evah!:rolleyes:

:off:

I still consider Legend as fast food.
But okay, the MTV generation likes it fast and easy.

Good for you.:)

Rivendell
09-09-08, 23:55
Come on, let's all settle down please.
There's really no need to get so worked up about it. It's not the first time, and it won't be the last time that someone says TR X kicks TR Y's ass - so there's not much point in arguing all the time.

Enough is enough really. One troll has gone back under the bridge, there needent be any more.
;)

peeves
09-09-08, 23:59
Come on, let's all settle down please.
There's really no need to get so worked up about it. It's not the first time, and it won't be the last time that someone says TR X kicks TR Y's ass - so there's not much point in arguing all the time.

Enough is enough really. One troll has gone back under the bridge, there needent be any more.
;)

Well said. Let's calm down everyone. Riv's right there ain't no point in arguing.

b0bb13
10-09-08, 00:00
:vlol:Oh that's funny!:D

EDIT: ****!Wrong thread.:o

TRhalloween
10-09-08, 14:33
Well Remember the video of AOD vs. Legend I'll get it on youtube
click here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZVMJzhDhjZI)

Didn't prove anything really. Bit immature.

:vlol:Oh that's funny!:D

EDIT: ****!Wrong thread.:o

What thread did you mean to post it on? Sounds funny.:)

b0bb13
10-09-08, 14:55
What thread did you mean to post it on? Sounds funny.:)

This one:http://www.tombraiderforums.com/showthread.php?t=133875
I love that song,so cool.:vlol::D

Teeth
10-09-08, 15:55
Key:
Near-Perfect
Very Good
Awful

Tomb Raider: 10/10

A revolutionary game for its time, and even today it beats most modern games with its wonderfully spooky atmosphere, immaculate controls and perfect control scheme. Plus the camera always behaves itself.

Unfinished Business: 8/10

I'm going to mark down UB a little bit because of its extreme difficulty and the fact that the final level doesn't even work properly. Nevertheless, it's still a brilliant levelset that expands upon the TR1 locations in very clever ways.

Tomb Raider 2: 9/10

Tomb Raider 2 is more of the same pure brilliance that made up the first game, but is let down somewhat by very messy explanation of the story and extremely slow and tedious puzzles that are really just there to stretch out the game's length (Diving Area is made up completely of these, for example). It still sets a great atmosphere and is just as creepy as the first game in places. (YETIS. SPIDERS. FLOATING ISLANDS.)

Golden Mask: 10/10

My favourite TR game. It's dark, intense and great fun to play. Golden Mask has a style all of its own, and it's totally unique. The puzzles are much better here than in TR2, and Nightmare In Vegas is just magnificently insane. :D

Tomb Raider 3: 10/10

A return to form, and almost as great as the original, save for some confusing maze-like areas and a very high difficulty level.

The Lost Artifact: 8/10

Lost Artifact is, in stark contrast to TR3, very easy. Ammo is handed to you constantly so that by the time you get to the final battle you can just blast Sophia Lee in her reused-textured face with the rocket launcher (which you've now probably picked up more ammo for than in the entirety of TR3). Despite this, it's still very fun and explorable, a staple of the Gold series games, and the unique locations make the game very fresh and interesting.

The Last Revelation: 4/10

Ohhh, and it was all going so well. A very long, very tedious and very, VERY slow game that stretches out the gameplay of the 3 TR1 Egypt levels into 30. The puzzles are dragged out so much here that even TR2's are acceptable in comparison. Setting the entire game in Egypt and stopping the story for more exposition every five minutes makes it even more boring. I haven't made it to the end of the game in yea- zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.

Chronicles: 8/10

Chronicles gets a lot of stick for being short, but to be fair, that's kind of the point. It was just like a "TR4 Gold" to tide fans over until Angel of Darkness came out. In my opinion it's a brilliant game while it lasts, and it feels so much more like a TR game than Last Revelation. It's much more fast-paced and the locations are unique and interesting.

Angel Of Darkness: 1/10

Abysmal. Terrible. Disgraceful.

Just do a search for "Angel Of Darkness" with Teeth as the User Name to search for, and set the results as posts. I've already gone on and on and on about how utterly rancid this excuse for a TR game is.

Legend: 9/10

A return to great form, this is almost as legendary as the original TR trilogy. Its length and tedious motorbike puzzles are the only things stopping Legend from being one of the greatest games in the series. Also, Legend Lara is the perfect blend of her classic personality from TRs 1-3, before she went all miserable and shouty.

Anniversary:

Anniversary is a difficult game for me to rate. So I'll do it twice:

Anniversary As A Standalone Game: 10/10

Perfect. The controls are immaculate, the story is epic and the game is overall much longer than Legend. The levels' puzzles are fantastically complicated and the whole game is great fun to play. And damnit, Larson's sexy. :p

Anniversary As A TR1 Remake: 5/10

Oh dear God, they ruined it. The characters are awful cliched stereotypes and mere shells of their original selves, so many rooms were removed from the original, including most of the contents of the final two levels, the few flaws the original game had have not been fixed, the level designs seem really forced and lazy and don't pay respect to the original game, Natla's character is ridiculous and the way she talks is just cringeworthy compared to how cool she was in the original game, Lara is an emotional wreck and it's very stupid that she gets into such a state after killing one man, the rats are too small, what the hell happened to Vilcabamba, the Cistern and Tomb of Tihocan? Where's Unfinished Business everything's grey the original game's atmosphere is gone the Atlanteans are rubbish itsnotfairwahegjkrjgghnblbfkdn!!!!!! WHY DID THEY CANCEL CORE'S REMAKE???!!!

See, I told you it was difficult. :p

Underworld: My Predicted Rating: 10/10

It's going to be absolutely fecking fantastic. It's going to be as legendary and amazing as the original trilogy. Anniversary would've been flawless if it weren't for TR1's existence, and since this one isn't a remake, I know that it will be awesome. Hold onto your hats, ladies and gentlemen! :D

TRhalloween
03-10-08, 18:11
Anniversary:

Anniversary is a difficult game for me to rate. So I'll do it twice:

Anniversary As A Standalone Game: 10/10

Perfect. The controls are immaculate, the story is epic and the game is overall much longer than Legend. The levels' puzzles are fantastically complicated and the whole game is great fun to play. And damnit, Larson's sexy. :p

Anniversary As A TR1 Remake: 5/10

Oh dear God, they ruined it. The characters are awful cliched stereotypes and mere shells of their original selves, so many rooms were removed from the original, including most of the contents of the final two levels, the few flaws the original game had have not been fixed, the level designs seem really forced and lazy and don't pay respect to the original game, Natla's character is ridiculous and the way she talks is just cringeworthy compared to how cool she was in the original game, Lara is an emotional wreck and it's very stupid that she gets into such a state after killing one man, the rats are too small, what the hell happened to Vilcabamba, the Cistern and Tomb of Tihocan? Where's Unfinished Business everything's grey the original game's atmosphere is gone the Atlanteans are rubbish itsnotfairwahegjkrjgghnblbfkdn!!!!!! WHY DID THEY CANCEL CORE'S REMAKE???!!!

I hate Anniversary for both of those reasons.

-Roli-
03-10-08, 18:13
Tomb Raider:10/10
Tomb Raider 2: 10/10
Tomb Raider 3: 10/10
Tomb Raider LR: 10/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 9,5/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 9/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 6/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 5/10

:D

Blackmoor
03-10-08, 18:38
Tomb Raider - 10
TR2 - 9
TR3 - 10
TR4 - 9.5

TR5 - 6

AoD - 7
Legend - 7
Anniversary - 8

LaraCroft90
03-10-08, 19:28
Looks like everyone loves TR3. :D

White Rabbit
03-10-08, 20:15
Vijay: [...] The audio! We have re-used quite a few of the ambient tracks from TR1. [...] Especially the heartbeat one. It doesn't fit as well as it does in TR1"
I thought I heard something very familiar when I played 'Sleeping With the Fishes'. Turns out it's re-used again in TLA!

tizerist
03-10-08, 20:33
I thought I heard something very familiar when I played 'Sleeping With the Fishes'. Turns out it's re-used again in TLA!Actually, now that you mention it, yeah it was.

I reviewed it here actually
http://www.tombraiderforums.com/showthread.php?t=100200

Look what Magnus the Monkey wrote about my post in entry no 207 in this very thread:
http://themagnus.livejournal.com/

He hates me! LOL

illuminati30
03-10-08, 21:54
Tomb Raider: 9/10
Tomb Raider 2: 10/10
Tomb Raider 3: 7/10
Tomb Raider LR: 9/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 6/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 7/10 (too short)
Tomb Raider Legend: 6/10 (good game, not tomb raider though)
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 8/10

peffect
03-10-08, 22:58
TR 1~5: 10/10
TR AoD: 07/10
TR L: 08/10
TR A: 07/10 (06/10 when being serious)

And I can see TR U being rated 08/10...

_ush2_
04-10-08, 11:11
Tomb Raider 1:7/10
Tomb Raider 2:8/10
Tomb Raider 3:7/10
Tomb Raider 4:9/10
Tomb Raider 5:haven't Played Yet
Tomb Raider 6:3/10
Tomb Raider 7:10/10
Tomb Raider AE :10/10

:)

TRhalloween
21-11-08, 17:51
Underworld so far gets a 10/10 :)

Lufik
24-11-08, 19:14
TR Legend 10/10
TR Anniversary 10/10
TR Underworld 10/10

:D I love TR by Crystal D. :)

Andariel
24-11-08, 20:21
Tomb Raider I - 8/10
Tomb Raider II - 9/10
Tomb Raider III - 8/10
Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation - 9/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles - 9/10
Tomb Raider: The Angel Of Darkness - 6/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 6/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 6/10 (rented)

The classic TR's created by Core are my favorites and I don't think anything new could surpass them to be honest.

AmericanAssassin
25-11-08, 02:40
I'm having a lot of trouble rating TRU at the moment, but this is what everything gets as of this minute...

1. Tomb Raider 10
2. Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation 9.5
3. Tomb Raider II 9.5
4. Tomb Raider: Chronicles 9
5. Tomb Raider: Underworld 8.5
6. Tomb Raider: Anniversary 8
7. Tomb Raider: Legend 7.5
8. Tomb Raider: The Angel of Darkness 7
9. Tomb Raider III 7

Tomb of Legends
25-11-08, 02:43
TRU 8.5? Didnt you rate it at 3 and bash the **** out of it at somepoint...

Tomb Raider 1 - 10
Tomb Raider 2 - 10
Tomb Raider 3 - 7.5
Tomb Raider 4 - 7.8 (Havent finished it ever)
Chronicles -8 (Just because of VCI)
AOD - 7.5
Legend - 7.7
Anniversary - 9.5
Underworld -

methos
25-11-08, 02:48
Tomb Raider: 8/10
Tomb Raider 2: 8/10
Tomb Raider 3: 4/10
Tomb Raider LR: 8/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 4/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 3/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 9/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 8/10
Tomb Raider Underworld: 9.5/10

M

AmericanAssassin
25-11-08, 02:48
TRU 8.5? Didnt you rate it at 3 and bash the **** out of it at somepoint...

I rated it a 4 at one point, because the camera is the worst in the video game industry and Thailand almost put me to sleep. Mexico more than made up for that, and it just kept getting better. I explained it in the TRU thread a bit more, but the second half of TRU is truly amazing. :)

Paddy
25-11-08, 02:54
Can only rate the ones I played.


Tomb Raider - 6/10
Tomb Raider 2 - 7/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 7/10
Last Revelation - 8/10
Chronicles - Yet to play
Angel Of Darkness - 5/10
Legend - 9/10
Anniversary - 9/10
Underworld - Yet to play

Ward Dragon
25-11-08, 04:07
tr1: 9/10
tr2: 8/10
tr3: 9/10
tr4: 7/10
tr5: 7/10
aod: 7/10
legend: 4/10 (raised to 6/10 for next-gen mode with voice volume off)
tra: 8/10

Scores subject to change pending replay of the games :p (I haven't played through the classics in a long time because I like to wait until I forget the level design so i can enjoy it more. I think it's time to replay them very soon.)

tru 9/10

Edit: I have no idea why the post keeps changing some of my capital letters to lowercase :confused:

Swaye
25-11-08, 09:15
Tomb Raider - never played it :( i know, boo
Tomb Raider 2 - 9,5/10 (my first ever tr, lovely memories)
Tomb Raider 3 - 10/10
Tomb Raider 4 - 10/10
Tomb Raider 5 - 8/10
Tomb Raider AOD - 9,5/10 (for some reason I loved the game :D)
Tomb Raider Legend - 8,5/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 9,5/10
Tomb Raider Underworld - yet to play it

Muhammad
25-11-08, 09:38
Tomb Raider - 9/10
Tomb Raider 2 - 9/10
Tomb Raider 3 - 10/10
Tomb Raider 4 - 8/10
Tomb Raider 5 - 8/10
Tomb Raider AOD - 7/10
Tomb Raider Legend - 9/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary - 9/10
Tomb Raider Underworld - 10/10

Forum Quorum
25-11-08, 09:54
Tomb Raider: 10/10
Tomb Raider 2: 10/10
Tomb Raider 3: 10/10
Tomb Raider LR: 7/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 7/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 7/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 5/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 3/10

kooky
25-11-08, 10:19
Tomb Raider 1: 9.5/10
Tomb Raider 2: 7/10
Tomb Raider 3: 10/10
Tomb Raider LR: 10/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 6/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 9/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 7.5/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 8/10
Tomb Raider Underworld, Still haven't played it yet

tranniversary119
25-11-08, 14:13
Tomb Raider 1: 8/10
Tomb Raider 2: 9/10
Tomb Raider 3: 8/10
Tomb Raider LR: 7/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 4/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 5/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 8/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 7.5/10
Tomb Raider Underworld: 8.5/10

Tomb_of_Darkns
25-11-08, 14:41
Tomb Raider 1: 9/10
Tomb Raider 2: 9/10
Tomb Raider 3: 9/10
Tomb Raider LR: 7/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 5/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 5/10 (i was supposed to rent TR legend except they gave me this game lol :p)
Tomb Raider Legend: 7/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 8.5/10
Tomb Raider Underworld: i'm only in the last part of thailand but so far i give it a 9/10 most likely will go to 10/10

Logie 12 =]
25-11-08, 14:52
Tomb Raider: 9/10
Tomb Raider 2: 10/10
Tomb Raider 3: 6/10
Tomb Raider LR: 8/10
Tomb Raider Chronicles: 9/10
Tomb Raider AoD: 4/10
Tomb Raider Legend: 9/10
Tomb Raider Anniversary: 7/10
Tomb Raider Underworld: 10/10