PDA

View Full Version : The General Tomb Raider 1 Level Elimination Game!


sheepman23
22-05-11, 21:32
There was originally a thread for Tomb Raider 1 - 3 levels, but I and a few others decided that the list was too long and confusing for the game to work well. So with that, I decided to split the three games up to make things work more easily. :tmb:

If you've never played before, here are the general rules:

1. Below is a list of all of the 16 levels from TR1 (I also included Croft Manor). All of the levels start out at 10 points.

2. In your post, you get the chance to "heal" one level (indicated by the + symbol in your post), and you get to "hurt" TWO levels (indicated by the - symbol in your post). This increases/decreases their amount of overall points.

3. Two posts a day.

4. No "double hurting" a level. For example, you can't do this:

+ The Lost Valley
- Cistern
- Cistern

4. When a level loses all of its points, it's eliminated from the game, and put on a list below (for instance, the first level eliminated would be #16, the second eliminated would be #15, and so on).

5. I'll update the current standings once a day in my first post, and also in a separate post as the topic goes along.

6. If there are any more questions, please ask!

EDIT: These are the new rules for the remaining part of the game (the top 3 levels):

1. The remaining 3 levels of the game will all restart at 20 points, regardless of what they had before.

2. In your post, you will get the chance to hurt ONE LEVEL.

3. Although you're still allowed 2 posts a day, your posts must be within 12 HOURS of eachother. So for example, if you vote at 8:00 a.m., you must wait until 8:00 p.m. or later to vote again, and if you vote at 8:30 p.m., you must wait till 8:30 a.m. before you vote again. This will hopefully keep things a little more fair as we move into the important rounds of the game. :tmb:

4. Like in the regular part of the game, when a level loses all of its points, it will be put on the "eliminated" list.

5. For Thursday, Friday, and Saturday, I will update the standings in a separate post and the opening post. However, for Sunday through Friday next week, I WILL BE GONE, so tomee (thanks again for his tremendous support :tmb:) will be updating the standings in separate posts. :) Chances are that the game will end while I'm gone; if that's the case, I'll do the final summary of it when I get back, and all of that stuff, and then we can move on to TR2! :jmp:

6. If there are any other questions regarding the final rounds of the game, please ask! :D

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 14
St. Francis Folly - 12
Palace Midas - 18

ELIMINATED

4. Obelisk of Khamoon
5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

sheepman23
23-05-11, 11:38
Nobody? Oh well...

+ Obelisk of Khamoon
- Cistern
- Tomb of Qualopec

tomee
23-05-11, 13:03
+ Cistern
- Caves
- Colosseum (I like this level, but it's not as impressive as the previous ones)

jajay119
23-05-11, 13:07
+Cistern
-Croft Manor
-Natla's Mines

peeves
23-05-11, 14:27
+Cistern
-Tomb of Qualopec
-City of Vilcabamba

sheepman23
23-05-11, 20:48
+ The Lost Valley
- Croft Manor
- Cistern

Current Standings

Croft Manor - 8
Caves - 8
City of Vilcabamba - 9
The Lost Valley - 11
Tomb of Qualopec - 8
St. Francis Folly - 10
Colosseum - 9
Palace Midas - 11
Cistern - 10
Tomb of Tihocan - 10
City of Khamoon - 10
Obelisk of Khamoon - 11
Sanctuary of the Scion - 10
Natla's Mines - 9
Atlantis - 10
The Great Pyramid - 10

moodydog
23-05-11, 20:55
Natlas mines +
Vilca -
Obe' Khamo -

sheepman23
24-05-11, 11:44
+ City of Vilcabamba
- Cistern
- Colosseum

jajay119
24-05-11, 11:53
+ Cistern
- Caves
- City of Khamoon

....

The Cistern certainly seems a sticking point!

sheepman23
24-05-11, 11:56
^ It seems I'm totally against the Cistern, while everybody else likes it. :rolleyes: :D I don't hate it at all, I just think it's the weakest level in TR1.

tomee
24-05-11, 13:51
^ It seems I'm totally against the Caves, like everybody else. :D I hate it, I think it's the weakest level in TR1.

corrected. ;)

+Cistern
-Caves
-Colosseum

Jester Head
24-05-11, 14:09
+The Cistern
-Caves

And, for the controversy

-Lost Valley.

peeves
24-05-11, 14:36
+Lost Valley
-Caves
-Tomb of Qualopec

domino92
24-05-11, 17:25
+Lost Valley
-Caves
-Sant Francis' Folley

jackles
24-05-11, 17:27
Official?



:confused:

peeves
24-05-11, 18:47
+Lost Valley
-Caves
-Tomb of Qualopec

sheepman23
24-05-11, 20:51
Official?



:confused:

Well, not really - I just thought it would make the title sound catchier. :D

+ Obelisk of Khamoon
- Atlantis
- Cistern

Current Standings

Croft Manor - 8
Caves - 2
City of Vilcabamba - 8
The Lost Valley - 13
Tomb of Qualopec - 6
St. Francis Folly - 9
Colosseum - 8
Palace Midas - 11
Cistern - 12
Tomb of Tihocan - 10
City of Khamoon - 9
Obelisk of Khamoon - 11
Sanctuary of the Scion - 10
Natla's Mines - 10
Atlantis - 9
The Great Pyramid - 10

jajay119
24-05-11, 21:04
+Cistern
-Caves
-Croft Manor

sheepman23
25-05-11, 11:39
+ Tomb of Tihocan
- Cistern
- Croft Manor

peeves
25-05-11, 13:57
+Cistern
-Caves
-Tomb of Qualopec

jajay119
25-05-11, 14:13
+Sanctuary of the Scion
-Vilcabamba
-Tomb of Qualopec

tomee
25-05-11, 14:16
+Lost valley
-Caves
-City of Vilcabamba

peeves
25-05-11, 16:19
+Lost Valley
-City of Vilcabamba
-Tomb of Qualopec

sheepman23
25-05-11, 23:48
...and Caves becomes the last place finisher for the TR1 thread.

Why the hate for Vilcabamba? :(

+ City of Vilcabamba
- Cistern
- Atlantis

Current Standings

Croft Manor - 6
City of Vilcabamba - 6
The Lost Valley - 15
Tomb of Qualopec - 3
St. Francis Folly - 9
Colosseum - 8
Palace Midas - 11
Cistern - 12
Tomb of Tihocan - 11
City of Khamoon - 9
Obelisk of Khamoon - 11
Sanctuary of the Scion - 11
Natla's Mines - 10
Atlantis - 8
The Great Pyramid - 10

ELIMINATED

16. Caves

Spong
25-05-11, 23:51
+ Sanctuary of the Scion
- The Lost Valley
- St. Francis Folly

sheepman23
26-05-11, 11:48
+ Obelisk of Khamoon
- Cistern
- Tomb of Qualopec

Jester Head
26-05-11, 12:03
+ City Of Vilcabamba
- Croft Manor
- Tomb Of Tihocan

jajay119
26-05-11, 12:12
+ Cistern
-Vilcabamba
-Tomb of Qualopec

peeves
26-05-11, 14:08
+Cistern
-City of Vilcabamba
-Tomb of Qualopec

cezy rockeru
26-05-11, 14:17
+ The Lost Valley
- Atlantis
- Croft Manor

peeves
26-05-11, 14:20
+Cistern
-City of Vilcabamba
-Tomb of Qualopec

Carlisle
26-05-11, 19:26
+ Obelisk of Khamoon
- Croft Manor
- Natla's Mines

jajay119
26-05-11, 20:01
+Cistern
-City of Vilcabamba
-Tomb of Qualopec

Between you and I the Cistern shall not die LOL.


.....................

+ Cistern
- Natla's Mines
- Vilcabamba

sheepman23
26-05-11, 20:01
+ City of Vilcabamba
- Cistern
- Colosseum

Current Standings

Croft Manor - 3
City of Vilcabamba - 4
The Lost Valley - 15
St. Francis Folly - 8
Colosseum - 7
Palace Midas - 11
Cistern - 14
Tomb of Tihocan - 10
City of Khamoon - 9
Obelisk of Khamoon - 13
Sanctuary of the Scion - 12
Natla's Mines - 8
Atlantis - 7
The Great Pyramid - 10

ELIMINATED

15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

Jester Head
26-05-11, 22:39
D: It seems I will not be able to save Vilcabamba... So I'll try to, at least save Atlantis. It CAN'T go that soon, it's one of the best levels!

+ Atlantis
- Croft Manor
- Tomb Of Tihocan

sheepman23
26-05-11, 22:42
^ I'll help you save Vilcabamba! :tmb: Unless one of my other favorites begins getting bashed...

Spong
27-05-11, 01:38
+ Sanctuary of the Scion
- The Lost Valley
- St. Francis Folly

jajay119
27-05-11, 11:25
+Atlantis
-Vilcabamba
-Natla's Mines

sheepman23
27-05-11, 12:24
+ City of Vilcabamba
- Cistern
- Colosseum

tomee
27-05-11, 12:44
+ Atlantis
- Colosseum
- Croft manor

peeves
27-05-11, 14:13
+Cistern
-Vilcabamba
-Natla's Mines

sheepman23
27-05-11, 18:05
...OK I give up on Vilcabamba too. I tried my hardest but the hole that it's in is way too deep... :pi:

+ Natla's Mines
- Cistern
- Atlantis

Current Standings

Croft Manor - 1
City of Vilcabamba - 3
The Lost Valley - 14
St. Francis Folly - 7
Colosseum - 5
Palace Midas - 11
Cistern - 13
Tomb of Tihocan - 9
City of Khamoon - 9
Obelisk of Khamoon - 13
Sanctuary of the Scion - 13
Natla's Mines - 7
Atlantis - 9
The Great Pyramid - 10

ELIMINATED

15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

charliesewell
27-05-11, 18:34
+ Atlantis
- The Cistern
- Croft Manor

:D

tomee
28-05-11, 07:08
+ Vilcabamba (I changed my mind about it (colosseum has to go before it.)
- lost valley (Lol guys you overfame that level)
- colosseum

sheepman23
28-05-11, 13:46
^ Overframing Lost Valley? It's a SPECTACULAR LEVEL!!!! :yah:

+ City of Vilcabamba
- Cistern
- Atlantis

peeves
28-05-11, 14:01
+Cistern
-Vilcabamba
-Natla's Mines

tomee
28-05-11, 14:56
^ Overframing Lost Valley? It's a SPECTACULAR LEVEL!!!! :yah:

+ City of Vilcabamba
- Cistern
- Atlantis

1st
+ Natla's mines
- Colosseum
- City of khamon

2nd
Why sticking to the view? It's like judging the book from the cover. ;)

3rd
Croft manor is actually Lara's home (at least in TRI TRII and TRIII)
and as it's done you should post the current standings. ;)

peeves
28-05-11, 15:12
+Cistern
-Vilcabamba
-Natla's Mines

sheepman23
28-05-11, 15:57
Why sticking to the view? It's like judging the book from the cover. ;)

Because Lost Valley truly is an AMAZING level. I'm not judging a book by its cover, either - I absolutely love everything about it. :tmb:

Croft manor is actually Lara's home (at least in TRI TRII and TRIII)
and as it's done you should post the current standings. ;)

Alright, I'll make sure I changed the name. And I always do one update a day, on my afternoon post for votes, but I'll do one now to make you happy... :P

+ Natla's Mines
- Cistern
- Atlantis

Current Standings

City of Vilcabamba - 3
The Lost Valley - 13
St. Francis Folly - 7
Colosseum - 3
Palace Midas - 11
Cistern - 12
Tomb of Tihocan - 9
City of Khamoon - 8
Obelisk of Khamoon - 13
Sanctuary of the Scion - 13
Natla's Mines - 7
Atlantis - 8
The Great Pyramid - 10

ELIMINATED

14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

jajay119
28-05-11, 17:35
+ St Francis Folly
- Natla's mines
- Collusseum

_Awestruck_
28-05-11, 17:41
+ Obelisk
- City of Vilcabamba
- Natla's Mines

tomee
29-05-11, 12:47
+ Natla's mines
- City of Khamon
- Colosseum

peeves
29-05-11, 14:15
+Cistern
-City of Vilcabamba
-Natla's Mines

sheepman23
29-05-11, 14:35
Will someone help me out with Cistern please? :D That level really needs to go. :tmb:

+ Natla's Mines
- Cistern
- Colosseum (not a bad level but it's a weaker one)

Current Standings

City of Vilcabamba - 1
The Lost Valley - 13
St. Francis Folly - 8
Palace Midas - 11
Cistern - 12
Tomb of Tihocan - 9
City of Khamoon - 7
Obelisk of Khamoon - 14
Sanctuary of the Scion - 13
Natla's Mines - 6
Atlantis - 8
The Great Pyramid - 10

ELIMINATED

13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

peeves
29-05-11, 14:40
+Cistern
-Vilcabamba bye bye
-Natla's Mines

Snazabaz
29-05-11, 14:43
+ The Lost Valley
- Cistern
- Palace Midas

:}hello friend
29-05-11, 14:58
+ St. Francis Folly
- Cistern
- Natla's Mines

tomee
29-05-11, 15:18
+ Natla's mines (this level divides the fans :O)
- Cistern (at first I boosted it but I think it's time to get rid of it)
- Lost valley

sheepman23
29-05-11, 15:51
^ I personally like Natla's Mines a lot. :tmb:

tomee
29-05-11, 16:42
well I don't want it to go. Not just yet. :D
And from now on, I'll help out the anti cistern brigade. :tmb:

herothing
29-05-11, 19:01
+ Lost Valley
- Cistern
- Natla's Mines

DIE NATLA!!

sheepman23
29-05-11, 22:03
+ Natla's Mines (LIVE, LIVE!!!!!) :D
- Cistern
- Sanctuary of the Scion

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 14
St. Francis Folly - 9
Palace Midas - 10
Cistern - 8
Tomb of Tihocan - 9
City of Khamoon - 7
Obelisk of Khamoon - 14
Sanctuary of the Scion - 12
Natla's Mines - 5
Atlantis - 8
The Great Pyramid - 10

ELIMINATED

12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

tr fan 4 ever
30-05-11, 06:05
+ The Lost Valley
- Cistern
- Obelisk of Khamoon

jajay119
30-05-11, 06:35
+Cistern
-City of Khamoon
- Natla's mines (DIE DIE! (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCoAwkCNUaU))

FloTheMachine
30-05-11, 10:19
The Cistern +
Obelisk of the Khamoon -
St. Francis' Folly -

^_______^

tomee
30-05-11, 12:43
+ Natla's mines
- Cistern
- Lost valley

sheepman23
30-05-11, 13:53
+ Natla's Mines
- Sanctuary of the Scion
- Cistern

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 14
St. Francis Folly - 8
Palace Midas - 10
Cistern - 8
Tomb of Tihocan - 9
City of Khamoon - 6
Obelisk of Khamoon - 12
Sanctuary of the Scion - 11
Natla's Mines - 6
Atlantis - 8
The Great Pyramid - 10

ELIMINATED

12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

Snazabaz
30-05-11, 14:00
+ St. Francis Folly
- Cistern
- Palace Midas

peeves
30-05-11, 14:35
+Lost Valley
-Natla's Mines
-Atlantis

sheepman23
30-05-11, 18:30
+ Natla's Mines
- Cistern
- Atlantis

Dark Wiseman
31-05-11, 04:47
+ Palace Midas
- The Lost Valley
- Sanctuary of the Scion

tomee
31-05-11, 14:43
+ Natla's mines
- Lost valley
- Cistern

sheepman23
31-05-11, 14:45
+ Natla's Mines
- Cistern
- The Great Pyramid

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 13
St. Francis Folly - 9
Palace Midas - 10
Cistern - 4
Tomb of Tihocan - 9
City of Khamoon - 6
Obelisk of Khamoon - 12
Sanctuary of the Scion - 10
Natla's Mines - 8
Atlantis - 6
The Great Pyramid - 9

ELIMINATED

12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

jajay119
31-05-11, 14:56
+ Cistern
-Natla's Mines
- City of Khamoon

sheepman23
31-05-11, 19:03
+ Palace Midas
- Cistern
- Sanctuary of the Scion

peeves
31-05-11, 19:19
+Lost Valley
-Natla's Mines
-Atlantis

jajay119
31-05-11, 20:15
+Atlantis
-Natla's Mines
-City of Khamoon

peeves
31-05-11, 21:36
+Lost Valley
-Natla's Mines
-Atlantis

StefanJ94
31-05-11, 22:01
+ Natla's Mines
- St. Francis Folly
- Palace Midas

Alex Shepherd
31-05-11, 22:36
+ Palace Midas
- St. Francis' Folly
- Sanctuary of the Scion
I like these 2 levels but it doesn't really impress me that much like others...

sheepman23
31-05-11, 23:03
A question - when we get down to 3 levels, should I change the voting to:

- 1 hurt and 1 heal
- 1 hurt and no heals
- End the game, placing the final 3 by how many points they have remaining

Any of them could really work... what do you guys think? :)

:}hello friend
01-06-11, 00:16
+ St. Francis
- Cistern
- Tomb of Tihocan

peeves
01-06-11, 01:19
A question - when we get down to 3 levels, should I change the voting to:

- 1 hurt and 1 heal
- 1 hurt and no heals
- End the game, placing the final 3 by how many points they have remaining

Any of them could really work... what do you guys think? :)

1 hurt and no heals would work.

tr fan 4 ever
01-06-11, 07:44
+ Natla's Mines
- Cistern
- City of Khamoon

tomee
01-06-11, 12:14
+ Atlantis
- City of Khamon
- Lost valley

A question - when we get down to 3 levels, should I change the voting to:

- 1 hurt and 1 heal
- 1 hurt and no heals
- End the game, placing the final 3 by how many points they have remaining

Any of them could really work... what do you guys think? :)

I think when we have four levels, we should vote 1hurt 1heal
when we have three (or two if 1hurt 1heal works) all the remaining levels should get a higher number (20 for example) and we have only one hurt. Oh and at this time we should only be able to vote in perfect 12 hours, so no one can vote rapidly.
I think this would work very well, what do you think?

Carlisle
01-06-11, 12:17
+ The Great Pyramid
- Cistern
- Natla's Mines

sheepman23
01-06-11, 14:18
I think when we have four levels, we should vote 1hurt 1heal
when we have three (or two if 1hurt 1heal works) all the remaining levels should get a higher number (20 for example) and we have only one hurt. Oh and at this time we should only be able to vote in perfect 12 hours, so no one can vote rapidly.
I think this would work very well, what do you think?

Hmm, not a bad idea. The problem is that with one hurt and one heal, the points for the levels will never really tend to tip in the lower direction, since a hurt and a heal cancel out (whereas the way we do it now, it's always -1 to the overall points when you post). Which is why I think we should maybe stick with 2 hurts and 1 heal until we get to the final 3, and then move the final 3 up to 20 points and do 1 hurt. And yes, limiting it to a perfect 12 hours would be good. :tmb:

+ Natla's Mines
- Cistern (almost there!)
- The Great Pyramid

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 14
St. Francis Folly - 8
Palace Midas - 11
Cistern - 1
Tomb of Tihocan - 8
City of Khamoon - 2
Obelisk of Khamoon - 12
Sanctuary of the Scion - 8
Natla's Mines - 6
Atlantis - 6
The Great Pyramid - 9

ELIMINATED

12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

:}hello friend
01-06-11, 14:20
+ Folly
- Cistern
- Tomb of Tihocan

tomee
01-06-11, 15:02
+ Atlantis
- Lost valley
- Tomb of Tihocan

sheepman23
01-06-11, 19:30
Cistern is OUT!!!! :jmp: (I don't hate it, it just should've been gone a long time ago).

+ City of Khamoon
- Atlantis
- The Great Pyramid

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 13
St. Francis Folly - 9
Palace Midas - 11
Tomb of Tihocan - 6
City of Khamoon - 3
Obelisk of Khamoon - 12
Sanctuary of the Scion - 8
Natla's Mines - 6
Atlantis - 6
The Great Pyramid - 8

ELIMINATED

11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

charliesewell
01-06-11, 22:00
+ Lost Valley
- City of Khamoon
- The Great Pyramid

sheepman23
02-06-11, 11:55
+ Natla's Mines
- Atlantis
- The Great Pyramid

tomee
02-06-11, 13:44
+ Atlantis
- Lost valley
- Obelisk of Khamon

sheepman23
02-06-11, 18:44
+ Natla's Mines
- Sanctuary of the Scion
- Atlantis

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 13
St. Francis Folly - 9
Palace Midas - 11
Tomb of Tihocan - 6
City of Khamoon - 2
Obelisk of Khamoon - 11
Sanctuary of the Scion - 7
Natla's Mines - 8
Atlantis - 5
The Great Pyramid - 6

ELIMINATED

11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

charliesewell
02-06-11, 20:10
+ St. Francis' Folly
- Tomb of Tihocan
- City of Khamoon

Dunnut7
02-06-11, 20:15
+ The Lost Valley
- Natla's Mines
- City of Khamoon

b.gluch
02-06-11, 21:50
+ Tomb Of Tihocan
- Obelisk Of Khamoon
- Atlantis

peeves
03-06-11, 02:04
+Lost Valley
-Tomb of Tihocan
-Natla's Mines

Dark Wiseman
03-06-11, 03:31
+ Palace Midas
- The Lost Valley
- Sanctuary of the Scion

tomee
03-06-11, 13:32
+ Atlantis (srsly?)
- Tomb of Tihocan
- Lost valley

woa 100th post in this thread :D

sheepman23
03-06-11, 13:49
City of Khamoon = out. It's one of my 9/10's for TR1, so I'm kinda sad to see it go... but the remaining levels are all pretty good for the most part. :tmb:

+ Natla's Mines
- Lost Valley (sorry, but this has too many, and yes, it is my second-favorite level of the game :o)
- The Great Pyramid

It's interesting, because while I really like Natla's Mines, I'm not a huge fan of the other two Atlantis levels...

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 14
St. Francis Folly - 10
Palace Midas - 9
Tomb of Tihocan - 4
Obelisk of Khamoon - 10
Sanctuary of the Scion - 6
Natla's Mines - 6
Atlantis - 5
The Great Pyramid - 5

ELIMINATED

10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

Soul
03-06-11, 14:20
+ St. Francis Folly
- Atlantis
- Natlas Mines

TheCoolJazz
03-06-11, 14:26
+ The Lost Valley
- Atlantis
- Obelisk of Khamoon


- Lost Valley (sorry, but this has too many, and yes, it is my second-favorite level of the game :o)

I'm bringing it back to the top so suck it :p

tomee
03-06-11, 15:34
+ Atlantis (Tihocan has to go first D: )
- Tomb of Tihocan
- Lost valley

sheepman23
03-06-11, 16:09
I've proposed an idea. After we finish the elimination games for all three games of the trilogy, I'll have the top 5 levels of this game, the top 6 levels of TR2, and the top 6 levels of TR3 (since there's more levels in those games :p) go against eachother in a final elimination game. That way, we'll be able to determine which level of the series wins, but not have a super 54-level long list. ;)

Anybody else think we should do this? :D

sheepman23
03-06-11, 20:12
+ Palace Midas
- Sanctuary of the Scion
- The Great Pyramid

charliesewell
03-06-11, 21:46
I've proposed an idea. After we finish the elimination games for all three games of the trilogy, I'll have the top 5 levels of this game, the top 6 levels of TR2, and the top 6 levels of TR3 (since there's more levels in those games :p) go against eachother in a final elimination game. That way, we'll be able to determine which level of the series wins, but not have a super 54-level long list. ;)

Anybody else think we should do this? :D

Sounds good! :D

+ Sanctuary of the Scion
- Tomb of Tihocan
- The Great Pyramid

b.gluch
03-06-11, 22:24
+ Tomb Of Tihocan
- Atlantis
- The Great Pyramid

Dark Wiseman
04-06-11, 10:07
+ Palace Midas
- The Lost Valley
- Sanctuary of the Scion

tomee
04-06-11, 13:21
+ Great piramyd
- Lost valley
- Tomb of Tihocan

sheepman23
04-06-11, 13:46
+ Natla's Mines
- Atlantis
- The Great Pyramid

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 12
St. Francis Folly - 11
Palace Midas - 11
Tomb of Tihocan - 2
Obelisk of Khamoon - 11
Sanctuary of the Scion - 5
Natla's Mines - 6
Atlantis - 2
The Great Pyramid - 2

ELIMINATED

10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

Carlisle
04-06-11, 15:02
+ The Great Pyramid
- Palace Midas
- Natla's Mines

sheepman23
04-06-11, 22:14
+ Natla's Mines
- Atlantis
- Sanctuary of the Scion

b.gluch
05-06-11, 05:14
+ The Lost Valley
- Atlantis
- The Great Pyramid

Dark Wiseman
05-06-11, 06:17
+ Palace Midas
- The Lost Valley
- Sanctuary of the Scion

tomee
05-06-11, 07:15
Noo Atlantis is out. :(

+ Great pyramid
-Tomb of Tihocan
- Lost valley

Johnnay
05-06-11, 11:22
Plus for Sancutary of Dat Scion

Nerfs for

The great pyramid
Tomb of tiochan

sheepman23
05-06-11, 13:00
...And the competition gets even closer as we lose both Atlantis and Tomb of Tihocan! Once we get down to the Final Three, the posting rules wil be changed to ONE HURT and no heals, and all of the levels will be moved up to 15 points, regardless of how many they have at the time. :tmb:

+ Natla's Mines
- The Great Pyramid
- Sanctuary of the Scion

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 11
St. Francis Folly - 11
Palace Midas - 11
Obelisk of Khamoon - 11
Sanctuary of the Scion - 3
Natla's Mines - 7
The Great Pyramid - 1

ELIMINATED

8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

tomee
05-06-11, 13:44
+ The great piramyd
- Lost valley
- Palace Midas

Carlisle
05-06-11, 14:10
+ The Great Pyramid
- Natla's Mines
- Sanctuary of the Scion

sheepman23
05-06-11, 21:16
+ Palace Midas
- The Great Pyramid
- St. Francis Folly (hate to do it, but it's like my 4th-favorite level of the game [and my other three favorites are still in], so it has too many points :rolleyes:)

Johnnay
05-06-11, 22:35
+ SOTS

- Natlas Mine
-and the great pyramid is finished

peeves
06-06-11, 02:38
+Lost Valley
-St. Francis Folly
-Palace Midas

Dark Wiseman
06-06-11, 12:30
+ Palace Midas
- The Lost Valley
- Sanctuary of the Scion

sheepman23
06-06-11, 13:10
I'll deliver the fatal blow to The Great Pyramid. :tmb:

+ The Lost Valley
- The Great Pyramid
- St. Francis Folly

I would save Natla's Mines... but I'm reaching the point where it's my second-least favorite on the list (behind SotS, which will be out pretty soon), so it's gonna have to go sometime. :(

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 11
St. Francis Folly - 8
Palace Midas - 11
Obelisk of Khamoon - 11
Sanctuary of the Scion - 2
Natla's Mines - 5

ELIMINATED

7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

StefanJ94
06-06-11, 13:13
+ Natla's Mines

- St. Francis Folly
- Sanctuary of the Scion

tomee
06-06-11, 14:02
I'll deliver the fatal blow to The Great Pyramid. :tmb:

:mad: 'FFFFFUUUUU' :p :hug:


+ Sancturay of the scion
- Lost valley (seriously it's time it gets eliminated :/)
- Palace Midas

Choosing hursts is getting quite painful, I like all of these levels. :(

sheepman23
06-06-11, 14:16
:mad: 'FFFFFUUUUU' :p :hug:

Sorry! :o It just had to go... ;)

Choosing hursts is getting quite painful, I like all of these levels. :(

I know what you mean. Pretty soon I'm gonna have to start giving Natla's Mines and St. Francis Folly all of my hurts... :(

sheepman23
06-06-11, 19:40
+ Palace Midas
- Sanctuary of the Scion
- Natla's Mines (after all of the times I saved it, now I've got to get rid of it... :()

bringmebliss
06-06-11, 20:03
+ St. Francis Folly
- Sanctuary of the Scion
- Natla's Mines

tomee
06-06-11, 20:49
+ Natla's mines
- Lost valley
- Palace Midas

I'm getting mad, SotS is also gone. I'm constanly losing my fav levels. xD :(

sheepman23
06-06-11, 21:23
I'm getting mad, SotS is also gone. I'm constanly losing my fav levels. xD :(

lol... now you know how I felt when everyone was against Madubu Gorge in the old topic! :p ;)

Surprised that none of my Top 3 levels (Palace Midas, The Lost Valley, and Obelisk of Khamoon) have went yet.

peeves
06-06-11, 21:40
+Lost Valley
-St. Francis Folly
-Palace Midas

:}hello friend
06-06-11, 22:03
+ Midas
- Natla's Mines
- Lost Valley

peeves
06-06-11, 22:04
+Lost Valley
-Palace Midas
-St. Francis Folly

:}hello friend
07-06-11, 01:08
No...
+ Folly
- Lost Valley
- Natla's Mines

b.gluch
07-06-11, 01:55
+ The Lost Valley
- Palace Midas
- Obelisk of Khamoon

sheepman23
07-06-11, 13:02
And with that, Sanctuary of the Scion is the next level out... which means that the remaining levels are our Top 5, ladies and gentlemen! :tmb: These are the 5 levels that will be competing in the "final level elimination game," which will take place after the TR1 - TR3 threads are all complete. :D

EDIT: Remember guys, this is when your vote really counts. Keep in mind that you get TWO POSTS A DAY, and it doesn't matter to me if you post both of your votes for the day in the same post, if that's the only time of the day you'll be on the forums. :tmb:

And what the heck is happening to Palace Midas?!?! :eek: NO, I WILL NOT LET IT GO DOWN THAT EASY!!!!!!

+ Palace Midas
- St. Francis Folly
- Obelisk of Khamoon (wow... one of my favorite levels of any game, and I'm trying to get rid of it :()

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 10
St. Francis Folly - 6
Palace Midas - 9
Obelisk of Khamoon - 9
Natla's Mines - 3

ELIMINATED

6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

Dark Wiseman
07-06-11, 13:37
And what the heck is happening to Palace Midas?!?! :eek: NO, I WILL NOT LET IT GO DOWN THAT EASY!!!!!!

I'm totally with you on that one; problem is, now I have to try and save St. Francis Folly as well. :( Now I'll have to split my heals up with whichever level needs it the most, Palace Midas or St. Francis Folly.

+ St. Francis Folly
- Lost Valley
- Obelisk of Khamoon (hate to do this :()

peeves
07-06-11, 14:01
+Lost Valley
-Natla's Mines
-Palace Midas

jajay119
07-06-11, 14:04
+Folly
-Palace Midas
- Natla's mines

peeves
07-06-11, 14:07
+Lost Valley
-Natla's Mines
-Palace Midas

tomee
07-06-11, 14:12
lol... now you know how I felt when everyone was against Madubu Gorge in the old topic! :p ;)

That was only the beloved Madubu gorge. But I lost 3 levels in a row and it seems Natla's mines is the next.
BTW don't worry, in a clean TR3 thread only, Madubu gorge will be eliminated swiftly after Kaliya ;)

+ Natla's mines Edit: (ew **** I was late)
+ St Francis folly
- Lost valley
- Palace Midas

sheepman23
07-06-11, 17:54
BTW don't worry, in a clean TR3 thread only, Madubu gorge will be eliminated swiftly after Kaliya ;)

Bring it on! :vlol:

AND OMG WHY DOES EVERYONE HATE PALACE MIDAS?!?!?!?! :mad:

j/k, I'm not really that mad, just a little unhappy :(

+ Palace Midas
- St. Francis Folly
- Lost Valley (it has too many!)

tomee
07-06-11, 18:49
ooh, I just realised I still have one vote. :cln: BTW I doubt any of us hate any of these levels, but we have to choose. :(

+ Folly
- valley
- Midas

:}hello friend
08-06-11, 00:20
+ Midas
- Lost Valley
- Natla's Mines

tomee
08-06-11, 06:05
+ Folly
- valley
- Midas

Dark Wiseman
08-06-11, 06:58
EDIT: Remember guys, this is when your vote really counts. Keep in mind that you get TWO POSTS A DAY, and it doesn't matter to me if you post both of your votes for the day in the same post, if that's the only time of the day you'll be on the forums. :tmb:

O.K. :lol

Vote 1:
+ Palace Midas
- Lost Valley
- Obelisk of Khamoon

Vote 2:
+ Palace Midas
- Lost Valley
- Obelisk of Khamoon

There's my two votes for today! :)

sheepman23
08-06-11, 11:42
^ OK, thanks! :D

Shoot... now Lost Valley is on a downhill slide. Do I save my second-favorite level of the game? Or ensure that my favorite level (Palace Midas) doesn't fall down there... oh, what to do...

+ Palace Midas
- St. Francis Folly
- Obelisk of Khamoon

At this point, it's all about defending Midas from everyone. :p

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 4
St. Francis Folly - 9
Palace Midas - 8
Obelisk of Khamoon - 5

ELIMINATED

5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

Soul
08-06-11, 12:34
YAY - St. Francis Folly ftw!

+ St. Francis Folly
- Obelisk of Khamoon
- Palace Midas

tomee
08-06-11, 13:10
+ Obelisk
- valley
- Midas

peeves
08-06-11, 13:45
+Valley
-Obelisk
-Folly

sheepman23
08-06-11, 17:58
+ Midas
- Obelisk
- Folly

peeves
08-06-11, 18:01
+Valley
-Obelisk
-Folly

Soul
08-06-11, 22:48
+ Folly
- Obelisk
- Midas

:}hello friend
08-06-11, 23:50
Two votes:

+ Midas
- Valley
- Obelisk

+ Midas
- Valley
- Folly D:

sheepman23
09-06-11, 01:50
And Obelisk of Khamoon bites the next bullet - bringing us to the final leg of the elimination game, guys! :tmb:

Now, the remaining three levels will move back up to 20 points - regardless of how much they have now - and instead of getting 1 heal and 2 hurts, you now will get 1 HURT. Also, to make things as fair as possible, you'll still be able to have 2 votes a day, but instead of allowing you to have two posts within the day, you'll now be required to wait 12 hours inbetween your votes. I hope that this isn't confusing to anyone... if there are any questions, please ask. :D

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 20
St. Francis Folly - 20
Palace Midas - 20

REMEMBER: Now you're only allowed one hurt. ;)

ELIMINATED

4. Obelisk of Khamoon
5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

!Lara Croft!
09-06-11, 02:43
- St Francis Folly.

Sorry darlin, but Palace of Midas and Lost Valley are so much more open...

sheepman23
09-06-11, 02:54
@ !Lara Croft! - :tmb:

I'm not trying to turn this thread into a review thing, but this is my reasoning:

Palace Midas > Lost Valley >> St. Francis Folly

First of all, all three levels are in my Top 20 levels of the series. Second of all, Palace Midas is my favorite because of the INCREDIBLE atmosphere and the most memorable death of the series, the hand of Midas. FRICKIN' SPECTACULAR, that is. Who would actually expect to get turned to gold from the hand of Midas? One might sit there and think, "Oh, that would be cool if it happened, but there's no way they'd be that awes- OMG IT'S HAPPENING!!!!!"

I love the open feel of Lost Valley. :) The machine cog puzzle is ace, climbing around the valley is FANTASTIC, and the most original concept of any TR level, IMO, were the dinosaurs. Throw in the most memorable encounter of the series with the t-rex, and this level is just a huge, HUGE success.

While I absolutely love St. Francis Folly, I can't help but feel that perhaps some parts of the level are too simplistic. For example, the Neptune puzzle. I think there should've been a huger swimming sequence here; really, it's quite simple to return to the surface, I did it on the very first playthrough without dying. On the other hand, the other three puzzles are more memorable, although it's too bad that Thor features a very random lightning ball. :rolleyes: Other than that, though, the level is tremendously memorable, with the opening chamber AND the tower room. :tmb:

sheepman23
09-06-11, 11:40
- St. Francis Folly

Dark Wiseman
09-06-11, 11:57
- The Lost Valley

Since we're on the subject, personally for me I view both Palace Midas and St. Francis Folly as 10/10 maps, and are my favorite and second favorite maps in TR respectively; whereas The Lost Valley is a 8/10 at best. It has too many flaws to for me to ignore. Maybe sometime in the future (when the number of review threads dies down) I'll do my own level by level review of TR and go into detail with all of the issues with it.

tomee
09-06-11, 15:00
Oh man.. I really don't know what to choose.. :(

I think I'll go with Lost valley.

The encounter with the dinosaur was amazing, and the cog puzzle was clever.

However, Palace Midas was bigger and there was more to explore (although the rooms with the led bars were kinda small). Same with the folly. Neptunus could've been a bit more memorable but the ather parts were really amazing.

:}hello friend
09-06-11, 15:14
My two votes
-- St. Francis Folly

Soul
09-06-11, 15:31
- Midas

tomee
09-06-11, 15:53
My two votes
-- St. Francis Folly

12 hours has to spend before voting again. If you don't have time to come back later, then you can't vote twice.

peeves
09-06-11, 17:06
- Midas

sheepman23
10-06-11, 04:00
- St. Francis Folly

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 18
St. Francis Folly - 16
Palace Midas - 18

ELIMINATED

4. Obelisk of Khamoon
5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

Dark Wiseman
10-06-11, 05:23
- The Lost Valley

Tiddlyfish13
10-06-11, 05:30
- St. Francis Folly
Aren't I allowed to heal a level still? If I am then...

+ LOST VALLEY

tomee
10-06-11, 13:16
^ Nope you're not

- Lost valley

peeves
10-06-11, 14:11
-St. Francis Folly

sheepman23
10-06-11, 16:07
- St. Francis Folly

Sorry to everyone who loves it, but of the three, it's my least favorite... :(

peeves
10-06-11, 16:08
- St. Francis Folly

Avalon SARL
10-06-11, 16:16
-St. Francis folly

tomee
10-06-11, 16:21
- St. Francis Folly

we still can't vote twice without having spent 12 hours after one. ;)

sheepman23
10-06-11, 16:23
tomee, you're gonna do a great job keeping this thing in line while I'm gone - I'm glad to have someone who's on the ball! :D :tmb:

And yeah guys - we're now spreading the votes out EVERY 12 HOURS, so when you vote once, YOU CAN'T VOTE FOR ANOTHER 12 HOURS. Hopefully that'll clear things up... ;)

Dark Wiseman
10-06-11, 17:13
- The Lost Valley

sheepman23
11-06-11, 05:15
- The Lost Valley

Current Standings

The Lost Valley - 14
St. Francis Folly - 12
Palace Midas - 18

ELIMINATED

4. Obelisk of Khamoon
5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

tomee
11-06-11, 06:05
-Lost valley

I think we already have a winner. The question will be who is the second and the third.

Dark Wiseman
11-06-11, 08:34
- The Lost Valley

sheepman23
11-06-11, 17:01
- St. Francis Folly

TO EVERYONE: Tomorrow through next Friday, I will be away from home, so tomee will be keeping track of the topic and posting updates. :tmb: Just thought I'd let everyone know. :)

peeves
11-06-11, 17:03
- Lost Valley

tomee
11-06-11, 18:26
- Lost valley

Tiddlyfish13
11-06-11, 18:29
Why does everyone hate Lost Valley? :confused:
Anyway:
- Palace Midas. I hope that'll piss some people off :vlol: I remember that being an annoying level.

b.gluch
11-06-11, 20:06
-Palace Midas

Come On Guys! The T-Rex! The T-Rex! He was awesome :(

:}hello friend
11-06-11, 21:36
Why does everyone hate Lost Valley? :confused:
Anyway:
- Palace Midas. I hope that'll piss some people off :vlol: I remember that being an annoying level.

Quit pissin' me off son.

- Lost Valley

Dark Wiseman
11-06-11, 22:09
- The Lost Valley

tomee
12-06-11, 06:39
- Palace Midas

Dark Wiseman
12-06-11, 10:23
- The Lost Valley

peeves
12-06-11, 13:49
- St. Francis Folly
I made a mistake about subtracting from lost valley for my last post.

trfanX34
12-06-11, 13:51
- St. Francis Folly.

tomee
12-06-11, 17:40
- Palace Midas
although it seems it is the winner.

Current standings

Lost valley - 7
St Francis folly - 9
Palace Midas 14

Eliminated

4. Obelisk of Khamoon
5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

Dark Wiseman
12-06-11, 22:57
- The Lost Valley

tomee
13-06-11, 10:17
- Palace Midas

:}hello friend
13-06-11, 18:35
- Lost Valley

aidanmalone
13-06-11, 18:36
- St Francis Folly

Dark Wiseman
14-06-11, 09:06
- The Lost Valley

jajay119
14-06-11, 09:24
-Palace Midas

tomee
14-06-11, 12:33
soory for not posting the stats yesterday guys. I was quite busy. :o

I think Palace Midas still has too much point. :/
- Palas Midas

Current standings

Lost valley - 4
St Francis folly - 8
Palace Midas 12

Eliminated

4. Obelisk of Khamoon
5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

TheCoolJazz
14-06-11, 13:04
- Lost valley

:}hello friend
14-06-11, 13:19
- Lost Valley

Soul
14-06-11, 13:33
- Midas

SoulReaver74
14-06-11, 13:36
- Palace Midas

tomee
14-06-11, 16:45
Current standings

Lost valley - 2
St Francis folly - 8
Palace Midas 10

Eliminated

4. Obelisk of Khamoon
5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

Dark Wiseman
15-06-11, 10:07
- The Lost Valley

Snazabaz
15-06-11, 10:19
- Palace Midas

Soul
15-06-11, 11:07
-Midas

tomee
15-06-11, 13:40
- Midas

peeves
15-06-11, 14:16
- Folly

:}hello friend
15-06-11, 15:31
- Lost Valley

tomee
15-06-11, 16:29
ooh it looks like this will be intresting. Lost valley is gone, but it reached a very nice place I think.:tmb:

Current standings

St Francis folly - 7
Palace Midas - 7

Eliminated

3. Lost valley
4. Obelisk of Khamoon
5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

Tiddlyfish13
15-06-11, 16:34
OMG I hate both of these levels! I love lost valley....:(
Well.... - Palace Midas :mis:

aidanmalone
15-06-11, 22:13
If these 2 are left ill go for
- Palace Midas

Killercowz
15-06-11, 22:15
- Palace Midas

Dark Wiseman
16-06-11, 06:06
- St. Francis Folly (just because it has more points, either deserves to win IMO)

tomee
16-06-11, 08:29
^ Yup I totally agree with you. But St. Francis folly was a little bit better to me. soo
- Palace Midas

Current standings

St Francis folly - 6
Palace Midas - 3

Eliminated

3. Lost valley
4. Obelisk of Khamoon
5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

jajay119
16-06-11, 09:05
Palace Midas unfortunately suffered bad design I think, it made no sense (although more sense than the TRA version it actually looked big and like a fulluly ruined palace not some random chamber) and was really basic. The folly for me is one of the icons of TR.

- Palace Midas

Tiddlyfish13
16-06-11, 18:04
Yeah, but for me, lost valley is an icon for tomb raider because the T-rex is right on the back, and the T-rex made Tomb Raider in the first place (according to an article I read) so everyone wanted to get a copy, and then they fell in love with the puzzles and such (same case here)

Soul
16-06-11, 19:16
- Palace Midas :D

-> Now take the last point guys ^^

Tiddlyfish13
16-06-11, 19:41
- Palace Midas! :D

tomee
16-06-11, 19:43
Wanna eliminate it? :D

Current standings

St Francis folly - 6

Eliminated

2. Palace Midas
3. Lost valley
4. Obelisk of Khamoon
5. Natla's Mines
6. Sanctuary of the Scion
7. The Great Pyramid
8. Tomb of Tihocan
9. Atlantis
10. City of Khamoon
11. Cistern
12. City of Vilcabamba
13. Colosseum
14. Lara's Home
15. Tomb of Qualopec
16. Caves

sheepman23
18-06-11, 04:48
Way to keep this thing going tomee! :tmb: And great to see the winner, even though I feel Palace Midas is more deserving... :rolleyes:

Will hopefully post the TR2 thread tomorrow! :jmp: