PDA

View Full Version : For those who had read Harry Potter 6


daggertail
31-07-05, 10:02
I just have a question:

Is the book good?
Is the book happy or sad?
Is it the best of all six?

Please answer just these questions. Don't post ANYTHING about the characters, the story or whatecer in the book. I will have to wait till Cristmass for the book to be translated in Bulgarian because I don't consider my English very good. I just want to know the answers of these questions.

Greenkey2
31-07-05, 10:14
Hi Daggertail!

Personally, these are my views about the book:

Is the book good?
It's good, but not the best of those JK has so far written. There's a lot of filling-in of backstory and some long patches going over what we already know. These are necessary for the story and how this book (and the last one) draw together plots, but they are sometimes a little tedious.

Is the book happy or sad?
There are bits to make you laugh, embarrassed, thoughtful, angry and weep your eyes out. In other words, a typical Harry Potter!

Is it the best of all six?
Not really, but it depends on your definition of 'best'. It is a good read, MUCH more revealing than any so far, but (for me) lacks the sheer OMG!! factor of previous titles, esp' Prisoner of Azkaban. It's such a well rehearsed formula; the initial clues, the slow build-up, the 'terrible truth' reveal and finally consolation with friends. It works very well, as always, but I left this book feeling like I'd only read the first chapter in a two-chapter book. Of all the series, this one is least able to stand alone, but is still an enjoyable, clever addition to the Harry Potter shelf.

Ah, there, said my piece. http://www.tombraiderforums.com/images/smilies/smile.gif

superstar
31-07-05, 10:14
yupp read it http://www.tombraiderforums.com/images/smilies/smile.gif
well honestly i think it is a nice book but not rowling's best (i think 4th one was)
well you have to read it to find out if it is good or sad ;) but it's a bit of both...
aww i think you can read it in english it is not that complicated and your english sounds really good from what you write here!

hope that was helpful :D

Nessie
31-07-05, 14:35
Is the book good?
It's okay, you should definitely read it if you like the series but it's rather bad for a Harry Potter book.

Is the book happy or sad?
It's not particulary much of either, but it's more sad.

Is it the best of all six?
No.

Oh, and your english seems fine - you should definitely give it a try.

hybrid-statue
31-07-05, 16:09
the book is good
if your a huge fan it is really sad
no i dont think it is the best but definatly worth reading

Angel666
01-08-05, 06:27
Okay... HBP fan comin through. http://www.tombraiderforums.com/images/smilies/smile.gif

I loved it. It is the best so far, IMO. It is both happy and sad. (I was extremely happy) And your english sounds pretty good and I recomend buying it.