Yay!
Sorry I'm posting late!
Best Level: Shakespeare Cliff
Worst Level: Willard's Lair
Toughest Level: Shakespeare Cliff
Best Room: The swamp with all the highlanders at the end of Willard's Lair
Best Trap: The boulder room of Willard's Lair
Best Puzzle: The library puzzle in Willard's Lair
Best Loading Screen: Sleeping With the Fishes
Best Enemy: Scuba Diver
Best Item: The Hand of Rathmore
Best Secret: The Nessie secret in Highland Fling
Toughest Secret: Same as above ^