I dont know much about the PS2 version but I did play the Wii version and thought it was alright. Had I not played the PS3 version first I would probably have no real complaints. It was a little empty in comparison and not too polished but I thought it had a charm to it. It reminded me a bit of the old school games with its silence and sort of more blocky looking areas. Maybe the PS2 version was worse but I think the hate for the Wii one is exaggerated